December 8, 2016

89th Academy Awards - First Nominations Predictions

If you know me, you know I really enjoy the Oscars. Don't get me wrong - I'm aware that they're mostly politics and showmanship and are ultimately completely pointless, but that's what makes them fun! Following the 2016 election was interesting on a reality TV show level, and hedging bets on the decisions of politicians and the outcome was fun, but the consequences of an election are way too real. The Oscars allows me to make bets and predictions and over-analyze the film industry with absolutely nothing that matters happening as a result. That, and screw you, I think it's a fun show.

So, every year for the past four or five years now, I've closely followed the precursor award season and predicted the nominees and winners for the Academy Awards, first posting them on this blog last year. I plan to have a more complete documenting of awards season this year than last (but by no means an exhaustive one due mainly to time constraints and honestly, probably lack of audience interest), and considered posting my guesses at the beginning of November once the season was in full swing (which is actually pretty late; most Oscar pundits start their early predictions as early as July). While my picks haven't changed a whole lot since the beginning of November, since then we've had some important steps toward having an actual educated guess on this year's nominees beyond simply knowing general Academy trends. The National Board of Review and the critics circles of New York, Los Angeles, Atlanta, and Washington, D.C., have all released their awards for the best films of the year this past week, and the Critics Choice Awards nominees have been announced in anticipation of the ceremony this Sunday.

What that means is now we have sufficient idea of not necessarily the exact trajectory of the Oscars, as the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences and critics are different people with different but somewhat similar tastes, but an idea of the general conversation surrounding this year's films in Hollywood, the Los Angeles Film Critics Awards being the best indicator of that as of now. So, this is my first of a planned three posts enumerating my Oscar nominee predictions, the other two planned to come shortly after Christmas (all wide release US films for 2016 will have been released and reviewed, screeners will have been sent out, the Critics Choice Awards will have been held, and we'll have the nominations for the Golden Globes and Screen Actors Guild Awards) and right before the nominees are announced (Golden Globes will have been held, and most guilds will have announced their nominees).

For right now, the Best Documentary Short Subject, Best Animated Short Film, and Best Live Action Short Film categories are being omitted, as it's fairly impossible to guess their trajectory at this juncture. My guesses for each category will be presented in order of likelihood to be nominated, and each category will be accompanied by a short explanation of my choices wherever necessary. I'll start from the "smaller" categories and work my way up to the big ones. All right, that's enough of an introduction, let's get into it...



Best Foreign Language Film

If you're not sure how this category works, each country chooses one film to represent them in this category, usually resulting in around 80 total submissions. It's a flawed system that ends in a lot of worthy foreign films being passed up, and, much like the Animated Feature and Documentary Feature categories, while definitely good to have, it does usually end in foreign films (or animated films, documentaries, etc.) more often than not never getting Best Picture nominations, although it's happened several times before.

This year's frontrunner seems to be Maren Ade's Toni Erdmann from Germany, which has immense goodwill and has garnered most foreign prizes from critics circles so far. Paul Verhoeven's controversial rape revenge thriller Elle has its star Isabelle Huppert emerging as a possible lock for a Best Actress nod, but the film itself may prove too intimidating for the Academy of mostly old white dudes (though, notably, the Academy made big leaps in diversity of age, genre, and race this past year in its membership). Chile's Neruda gets extra points for being directed by Pablo Larrain, who also directed English-language Best Picture threat Jackie this year, and while Iranian director Asghar Farhadi is widely considered the best of his homeland, The Salesman has not been getting glowing responses stateside, so I feel he's a safe bet but not an absolute shoo-in.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Toni Erdmann (Germany)
2. Elle (France)
3. Neruda (Chile)
4. The Salesman (Iran)
5. Fire at Sea (Italy)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Julieta (Spain)
7. Ma'Rosa (Philippines)
8. The Age of Shadows (South Korea)


Best Documentary Feature

The Academy recently released their shortlist of finalists for this category, and they certainly have their work cut out for them in choosing just five nominees, as this year's documentary field is filled with topical, stirring, and excellently crafted documentaries that all have their share of passionate fan bases. 

The frontrunner is Selma director Ava DuVernay's Netflix exclusive doc 13th about the history of racial prejudice in America specifically within the criminal justice system, with I Am Not Your Negro and the 8-hour theatrical edit of the ESPN miniseries O.J.: Made in America being close second favorites. Beyond that, it's pretty much anyone's game, though I'm giving the bump to Weiner, the amazing doc surrounding Anthony Weiner's New York City mayoral campaign amidst a sexting scandal, as it is a relatively lightweight but still thought-provoking examination of media and politics in a heated election year, as well as unfortunately remaining very timely given the recent separation of Weiner and wife Huma Abedin and the sleazy similarities to be noticed between the film's subject and our pussy-grabbing president-elect. 

Outside of those choices, it could go basically anywhere. I'm giving Cameraperson the edge for the fifth spot due to its subject being a female cinematographer, which is a bit of a rarity. With that in mind, general questions about cybersecurity post-Snowden could work in the favor of Alex Gibney's Zero Days. Tower, a doc about a school shooting, focuses on a political topic important to many Academy voters, but I wouldn't exactly designate it as "timely", unless a school shooting happens between now and January, which sadly is not out of the question. I'm leaving out Fire at Sea, which is also eligible in this category, as I think it'll be nominated for foreign film due to its timeliness regarding the European migrant crisis instead of here, as the Academy generally prefers American docs.

Predicted Nominees:
1. 13th (Ava DuVernay)
2. I Am Not Your Negro (Raoul Peck)
3. O.J.: Made in America (Ezra Edelman)
4. Weiner (Josh Kreigman and Elyse Steinberg)
5. Cameraperson (Kirsten Johnson)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Zero Days (Alex Gibney)
7. Tower (Keith Maitland)
8. The Eagle Huntress (Otto Bell)
9. Into the Inferno (Werner Herzog)


Best Animated Feature Film

In my estimation, we have three frontrunners to win Best Animated Feature, all of which are pretty much guaranteed nominations, which is actually really good. Most years there's usually a clear winner, an underdog, and a foreign movie that probably should win but won't. The Red Turtle's consistently great reception throughout its many festival runs (it doesn't get a normal US release until mid-January) has earned it a seat at the cool kids' table, which really only leaves the fifth slot open. I'm going with Sing for now as it's a late release that has garnered a surprising amount of positive attention and will likely be a box office success. While a major critical and commercial success, Finding Dory has been curiously left out of the conversation as of late, with Laika's Kubo and the Two Strings actually picking up the most wins from critics circles so far.

As for most likely winner, I have Moana as the frontrunner for a couple reasons. First, the general rule of this category is that the voters generally pick whichever film they like the animation style of the most, which usually defaults to the most competently composed computer-animated film of that year (with the exception of The Lego Movie, which is still a disgrace of a snub). In this case, Moana may have the edge, although Kubo and the Two Strings's eligibility in the Best Visual Effects category could mean otherwise (more on that in a second). The other things pushing Moana to the front is its Thanksgiving release (Zootopia and Kubo were both released in months atypical of winners in this category), classical Disney style (Moana reeks of Disney Renaissance, which they love), and will most likely get nominations for its amazing music. Zootopia has a brilliant and very timely script in its favor, yes, but perhaps the Academy would find it more conducive to inclusiveness to reward a story about ancient Oceanic mythology rather than another talking animal movie. Granted, if Moana were to win it would go to its two white directors, but what can you do?

Predicted Nominees:
1. Moana 
2. Zootopia
3. Kubo and the Two Strings
4. The Red Turtle
5. Sing

Potential Spoilers:
6. Finding Dory
7. Miss Hokusai
8. Your Name
9. The Secret Life of Pets
10. The Little Prince

Longer Shots:
11. Sausage Party
12. My Life as a Zucchini
13. Trolls
14. The Angry Birds Movie
15. Kung Fu Panda 3


Best Makeup and Hairstyling

This category infamously only has three nomination slots rather than five (which is particularly stupid when you consider that literally every movie has hair and makeup work), so predicting it is always tight. We don't have a shortlist yet, but the choices seem fairly simple to me. The Star Trek films have always had a decent showing in this category, only winning a handful of times but picking up a safe number of nominations. Star Trek Beyond was by no means a success or something the Academy cares about, but this category's nominations always feel like the voters go "yeah, that sounds like something that would be nominated for this", so it fits. Silence's sweaty hairy men and Jackie's note-perfect period detail of the Kennedy family should round out the nominations, with the latter being my frontrunner for the win. The other two slots, honestly, I believe are up for grabs.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Jackie
2. Silence
3. Star Trek Beyond

Potential Spoilers:
4. Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them
5. Hacksaw Ridge
6. Suicide Squad
7. Deadpool


Best Sound Editing

This category is basically synonymous with "sound design", so the general rule has always been that the loudest film wins. War movies are perhaps over-represented here, and after the NBR sung its praises last week, it looks like Hacksaw Ridge has triggered the Gibsonaissance, so I have it as the frontrunner here. Old-fashioned workman disaster dramas Patriots Day and Sully have been mostly positively received and will likely strike a chord with the older set within the Academy who will want to honor it somewhere, Arrival's technical merits are too numerous to count, and Star Wars has been nominated in this category several times, as the New Hollywood-born franchise is one of few blockbusters the Academy takes seriously to any degree.

There are numerous potential spoilers here, as these categories really do come down to "which sci-fi or war film did they like most?", so beyond Rogue One and Hacksaw Ridge, I'd say the remaining three slots are up for grabs.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Hacksaw Ridge
2. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
3. Arrival
4. Sully
5. Patriots Day

Potential Spoilers:
6. The Jungle Book
7. Deepwater Horizon
8. Live by Night
9. Passengers
10. Captain America: Civil War
11. Moana
12. La La Land


Best Sound Mixing

All conventional Oscar wisdom points to La La Land winning this category. Expectedly, musicals are quite often successful in this category due to the complications of mixing vocals with music and diegetic sound effects, and this film has gotten unanimous praise since its premiere at Venice. Rogue One is also a very safe bet here, being another category Star Wars typically shows up in, and Hacksaw Ridge's war movie edge will help it in this sound category as well as the last. I picked Sully for consistency and Silence for shits and giggles mostly, so the last two slots are a craps shoot to some extent.

Predicted Nominees:
1. La La Land
2. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
3. Hacksaw Ridge
4. Sully
5. Silence

Potential Spoilers
6. The Jungle Book
7. Deepwater Horizon
8. Patriots Day
9. Moana
10. Arrival


Best Visual Effects

The Jungle Book has been considered an early frontrunner to win this category since its release all the way back in April, with many critics calling it the Avatar of computer-generated animals. Comic book movies only sometimes make tracks in this category, but Doctor Strange has been particularly singled out for its Escher-style mind-bending effects work, so I'm betting it makes a showing here. Arrival will satisfy their need to reward "thinking man's sci-fi" in this category a la last year's Ex Machina, and Rogue One is basically a shoo-in to be nominated, as seven of the eight prior live-action Star Wars films have been nominated in this category. 

I have Civil War in the fifth slot for lack of a better idea of where the Academy's head is at. It's fairly standard fare as far as comic book movie effects go, though it is a pseudo-Avengers-level commercial hit and ensemble action piece that may draw their attention. Fantastic Beasts has a shot, though the Harry Potter universe is more often nominated for its sets and costumes than its VFX. Other possibilities that made it onto the shortlist are Sully, whose effects are minimal and by no means state-of-the-art but wouldn't be entirely undeserved, The BFG, which suffered mixed reviews but was praised for its motion-capture tech, and Passengers, which looks relatively impressive visually but also doesn't look that good. The weirdo inclusion on the list is Kubo and the Two Strings, eligible via a loophole in the wording of the VFX category rules that allows stop-motion animation to be counted as both an animated film and a live action film in many cases. It's an outside shot, but it's not unprecedented (The Nightmare Before Christmas was nominated in this category), and Kubo has gained unanimous praise for its impressive effects animation. Stranger things have happened.

Predicted Nominees:
1. The Jungle Book
2. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
3. Doctor Strange
4. Arrival
5. Captain America: Civil War

Potential Spoilers:
6. Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them
7. Sully
8. Passengers
9. The BFG

Would Be Kinda Weird:
10. Kubo and the Two Strings
11. Deadpool
12. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
13. X-Men: Apocalypse
14. Alice Through the Looking Glass


Best Costume Design

Do you like period pieces and frilly dresses? You should start predicting the Best Costume Design Oscar, because that's pretty much all the happens here. Jenny Beavan's win for Mad Max last year was a total fluke. Of all the period pieces vying for this prize, Jackie is the one with which most Academy voters will most closely identify, mostly because I'm sure a lot of them were alive during the event it shows. And while they may not have vested interest in 17th century Jesuits or wizards, Powell and Atwood are very frequently represented in this category. La La Land's predicted technical sweep and my hunch that the Academy will have a mild hard-on for Florence Foster Jenkins (but not too much - Stephen Frears hasn't impressed them immensely in the last several years despite directing a Best Picture nominee) are what helps round out my predictions. Outside of La La Land, Jackie, and Fantastic Beasts, though, any of the top few potential spoilers are distinct possibilities, either because of the reception to the film, the subject matter being up Oscar's alley, or recognition of the name of the designer. We'll have a clearer idea in due time.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Jackie (Madeline Fontaine)
2. La La Land (Mary Zophres)
3. Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them (Colleen Atwood)
4. Silence (Sandy Powell)
5. Florence Foster Jenkins (Consolata Boyle)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Allied (Joanna Johnston)
7. Live by Night (Jacqueline West)
8. Rules Don't Apply (Albert Wolsky)
9. Fences (Sharen Davis)
10. Hail, Caesar! (Mary Zophres)
11. Love & Friendship (Eimer Ni Mhaoldomhnaigh)


Best Production Design

This category is a matter of wondering whether the Academy will prioritize work by designers and filmmakers they are familiar with and love or work by more burgeoning artists who have, despite their lack of name recognition, done excellent work with subject matter that is right up the Academy's alley. The frontrunner to me at this moment is an effective tie between La La Land and Jackie. The former benefits from being an old-school Hollywood musical with heaps of praise and endless visual style; the latter benefits from having sets and props from a time period well-known by the Academy and similarly pulled off with incredible skill.

Beyond that, it's mostly a question of just how much of a lock their typical locks are. Fantastic Beasts is a likely nominee, as production designer Stuart Craig is a longtime Oscar favorite, particularly when working with the wizard world. Silence has longtime Scorsese contributor Dante Ferretti in charge of its art direction, and they will no doubt feel pressured to reward him. The fifth slot is a bit more of a toss-up, but I'm giving the edge to Live by Night, Ben Affleck's gangster drama that was recently given a Christmas Day limited release to compete for the Oscars. It's gotten good early word, particularly for its visuals, and there is great Oscar-friendly talent assembled on both sides of the camera, but I think the studio may have jumped the gun on trying to shoehorn it into an already very crowded December release slate. They'll definitely see it, but will they remember it? I'm giving it an edge in at least one category now because it's still too early to say it'll be ignored but also too early to completely rule it out.

The Jungle Book has a decent shot, even though the bulk of its sets were created in-computer, which doesn't disqualify it, as it shouldn't. Jeanine Oppewall is an Oscar favorite doing the art direction for a Warren Beatty film (Rules Don't Apply), but reaction to the film has been incredibly lukewarm and it hasn't been the callback for the director that it was meant to be. However, sometimes that doesn't matter if Oscar likes the man enough, and Beatty is something of a legend. Beyond that are period pieces and the occasional well-crafted sci-fi flick thrown in for kicks. The final slot or two could go essentially anywhere at this point, but the first three are effective locks.

Predicted Nominees:
1. La La Land (David Wasco)
2. Jackie (Jean Rabasse)
3. Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them (Stuart Craig)
4. Silence (Dante Ferretti)
5. Live by Night (Jess Gonchor)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Rules Don't Apply (Jeanine Oppewall)
7. Fences (David Gropman)
8. The Jungle Book (Christopher Glass)
9. Allied (Gary Freeman)
10. Arrival (Patrice Vermette)
11. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (Doug Chiang and Neil Lamont)
12. Love & Friendship (Anna Rackard)
13. Hail, Caesar! (Jess Gonchor)


Best Film Editing

The closest things to locks that I can see in this category are La La Land and Moonlight. Weirdly, this category is not often reserved for purely technical achievements as it once was (The Matrix and Terminator 2 won in this category, but films like them today probably wouldn't). Best Picture winners rarely do not have editing nominations, and these two films are two of the biggest films in that conversation. La La Land definitely has the upper hand, being a more obvious technical achievement, a musical, generally faster paced, and edited by someone who previously won working for this director, but Moonlight is melodic in its construction and its editing is damn near perfect. Any category in which Moonlight is nominated should definitely consider it as a threat to win due to the immense amount of goodwill surrounding it, but for now I'm saying the most likely nomination goes to La La Land.

Beyond that, Walker and Schoonmaker are both past Oscar nominees with known and celebrated work, so they're relatively safe bets. Right now, hype seems to be in Hacksaw Ridge's favor as the sort of middling technical achievement of the major movies in the conversation, but there are plenty of other Best Picture threats that may wow them. The nominations for the ACE Eddie Awards next month will make things clearer, but for now this is all we got.

Predicted Nominees:
1. La La Land (Tom Cross)
2. Moonlight (Joi McMillon and Nat Sanders)
3. Silence (Thelma Schoonmaker)
4. Arrival (Joe Walker)
5. Hacksaw Ridge (John Gilbert)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Sully (Blu Murray)
7. Manchester by the Sea (Jennifer Lame)
8. Hidden Figures (Peter Teschner)
9. Jackie (Sebastian Sepulveda)
10. Fences (Hughes Winborne)

Outside Shots:
11. The Jungle Book (Mark Livolsi)
12. Hell or High Water (Jake Roberts)
13. Live by Night (William Goldenberg)
14. Deepwater Horizon (Gabriel Fleming and Colby Parker, Jr.)


Best Cinematography

Very similar top five lineup as with Film Editing here. Once again, La La Land and Moonlight are the two definite locks, with Silence being just under a lock (I mean, it looks beautiful in the trailers, but will they like the movie?). Linus Sandgren is new to the game, but La La Land is stunningly shot. James Laxton is a similar nobody in regards to Oscar, but one of Moonlight's many points of unanimous praise has been its breathtakingly intimate camerawork. Rodrigo Prieto has only been nominated once for Brokeback Mountain, but he thrives in outdoor settings, which Silence will make great use of. 

Outside of that, things get a little messy between exceptionally well-shot pseudo-underdog efforts and recognized names, though not quite as open a field as with editing. I'm giving the edge to Arrival and Nocturnal Animals, oddly enough both Amy Adams vehicles - the former because of DP Bradford Young's previous work on projects they liked (most notably Selma) and their love for how Denis Villeneuve shoots his movies, and the latter because they usually enjoy Seamus McGarvey's work. Plus, the previous Ford/McGarvey outing, A Single Man, didn't give McGarvey the nomination, seen by many as a snub, so they may feel the need to compensate in the form of rewarding a starkly beautiful film.

Live by Night poses a real threat to the top five; the Academy will nominate Robert Richardson-shot films even if the camerawork isn't that great and they don't even like the movie that much. A few other technical powerhouses might sneak their way in, but outside of a handful of potential upsets, this category is somewhat cut-and-dry.

Predicted Nominees:
1. La La Land (Linus Sandgren)
2. Moonlight (James Laxton)
3. Silence (Rodrigo Prieto)
4. Arrival (Bradford Young)
5. Nocturnal Animals (Seamus McGarvey)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Live by Night (Robert Richardson)
7. The Jungle Book (Bill Pope)
8. Jackie (Stephane Fontaine)
9. Hail, Caesar! (Roger Deakins)
10. Lion (Greg Fraser)

Outside Shots:
11. Hacksaw Ridge (Simon Duggan)
12. The BFG (Janusz Kaminski)
13. Sully (Tom Stern)
14. The Light Between Oceans (Adam Arkapaw)
15. A Monster Calls (Oscar Faura)


Best Original Song

La La Land was considered the unbeatable winner in this category until Disney's Moana was released. While I'm still confident that two songs will be nominated for La La Land (the maximum under Academy rules), there are some good songs that might pose a threat. I'm giving La La Land a slight edge to win, though a big part of me believes that Moana will emerge the victor here, as it truly is a Disney movie stuck out of time, and has its music coming from the spectacular Lin-Manuel Miranda (who would be an EGOT should he win for this film, and the second person in a row to become an EGOT by winning for writing a Disney song). Hidden Figures should prove rousing as a late entry, and this is an easy category to suddenly be included in without warning, and we have a large selection of documentaries and animated films with great songs that could get in. The Academy is infamous for almost never following conventional wisdom with this category, so expect upsets pretty much regardless of what I predict.

Predicted Nominees:
1. "Audition (The Fools Who Dream)" (La La Land)
2. "How Far I'll Go" (Moana)
3. "City of Stars" (La La Land)
4. "I See Victory" (Hidden Figures)
5. "Can't Stop the Feeling" (Trolls)

Potential Spoilers:
6. "I'm Still Here" (Miss Sharon Jones)
7. "A Letter to the Free" (13th)
8. "Drive It Like You Stole It" (Sing Street)
9. "We Know the Way" (Moana)
10. "The Rules Don't Apply" (Rules Don't Apply)
11. "Back to Life" (Queen of Katwe)
12. "Angel by the Wings" (The Eagle Huntress)
13. "Try Everything" (Zootopia)
14. "Faith" (Sing)

Outside Shots:
15. "The Great Beyond" (Sausage Party)
16. "I'm So Humble" or "Equal Rights" (Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping)
17. "Moonshine" (Live by Night)
18. "The Empty Chair" (Jim: The James Foley Story)
19. "Take Me Down" (Deepwater Horizon)


Best Original Score

For obvious reasons, La La Land is considered the frontrunner for this category, and might be the only true lock, but I'm still treading lightly with this category, because there are honestly dozens of possibilities. I've heard decent cases made for basically every film listed below sneaking a nomination in for this category. Arrival seems like a fairly safe bet to me, though, given that they really like Johann Johannson's work (he's been nominated each of the last two years) and the score for Arrival is truly phenomenal. Star Wars usually makes a good showing in this category, and Michael Giacchino is an underrated but still loved composer in Oscar's eyes (he wrote and won an Oscar for the beautiful music in Up), so Rogue One seems also fairly safe. I'm somehow alone in this, but I consider Moana a very decent shot for a nomination, but admitting the fact that I'm the odd one out thinking that, the last two slots are the most particularly unpredictable, though it's truthfully more like four.

I suspect Florence Foster Jenkins will get just barely booted out of the bigger categories by other worthy choices, but I think it could manage here, as it has a composer they like and Frears's movies typically do well here. Returning favorites John Williams and Thomas Newman, both with nominations in the double digits, unfortunately were paired this year with mediocre films that haven't sustained much traction, but their respective efforts could find a way. Moonlight, Jackie, and The Jungle Book have all been noted for their great scores, so they are possibilities as well. Like with the song category, there's not much to completely rule out at this juncture.

Predicted Nominees:
1. La La Land (Justin Hurwitz)
2. Arrival (Johann Johannson)
3. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (Michael Giacchino)
4. Moana (Mark Mancina)
5. Florence Foster Jenkins (Alexandre Desplat)

Possible Spoilers:
6. Jackie (Mica Levi)
7. The Jungle Book (John Debney)
8. Moonlight (Nicholas Britell)
9. The BFG (John Williams)
10. Finding Dory (Thomas Newman)
11. Lion (Dustin O'Halloran and Hauschka)
12. The Light Between Oceans (Alexandre Desplat)
13. Hacksaw Ridge (Rupert Gregson-Williams)

Outside Shots:
14. Patriots Day (Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross)
15. Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them (James Newton Howard)
16. Hail, Caesar! (Carter Burwell)
17. Zootopia (Michael Giacchino)
18. Denial (Howard Shore)


Best Adapted Screenplay

Arrival and Silence are the closest things to locks in this category in my mind. Arrival's heady themes will rest much of the attention on the script (aside from Adams's performance), and Scorsese has a writing credit on Silence along with former nominee Jay Cocks. Scorsese scripts are often nominated, and this passion project adaptation of a beloved novel should do well. Outside of that, this category suffers from most of its more obvious possible choices not being exceptionally great movies. I'm giving Hacksaw Ridge and Hidden Figures the nod because - spoilers - I have them as Best Picture nominees, with which a screenplay nomination usually runs in tandem. The fifth slot is nebulous to me. 

Many pundits have the Denzel Washington-helmed Fences as a frontrunner for this category, but its eligibility is questionable to me because its writer, August Wilson, wrote the script over 10 years ago and is now dead. He also didn't write most of the version that has been released, with Tony Kushner doing much of the posthumous rewrites. I have other reservations about Fences being a major player for reasons I'll get into later. It definitely has a shot, so I've given it the fifth slot, but Nocturnal Animals, Sully, and Elle definitely stand to contest that.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Arrival (Eric Heisserer)
2. Silence (Martin Scorsese and Jay Cocks)
3. Hacksaw Ridge (Andrew Knight and Robert Schenkkan)
4. Hidden Figures (Allison Schroeder and Theodore Melfi)
5. Fences (August Wilson's ghost)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Sully (Todd Komarnicki)
7. Nocturnal Animals (Tom Ford)
8. Elle (David Birke)
9. Love & Friendship (Whit Stillman)
10. Lion (Luke Davies)
11. Certain Women (Kelly Reichardt)
12. Live by Night (Ben Affleck)


Best Original Screenplay

In my mind, we have three locks in this category - Manchester by the Sea, Moonlight, and The Lobster. The latter was an outside choice for a longtime, but its unexpected win for Best Screenplay with the Los Angeles Film Critics Association shows that there is still goodwill to be had for this oddball dark romantic comedy in Hollywood even seven months after its limited release. It wouldn't be a completely bonkers nominee either - the Academy enjoys its share of well-crafted sardonic fantastical comedies about the human condition (see also: Her, Adaptation, etc.), and Yorgos Lanthimos was previously nominated in the Foreign Language Film category for his film Dogtooth. Moonlight and Manchester are pretty undeniable nominees though, and the latter will be taking home the win by the looks of things right now.

I have Chazelle nominated here for La La Land, though I'm weary of everyone's confidence that it will be nominated here. It's a major frontrunner to win Best Picture, and while it's not unprecedented, it's highly infrequent that a movie win Best Picture without a screenplay nomination (it hasn't happened in almost 20 years). That said, it's a musical, and those typically don't land in this category, and unlike the Adapted category, there are plenty of incredibly worthy stories vying for a prize here that the Academy would enjoy. While I'm edging out my guesses with Hell or High Water, which has become something of a sleeper hit after being nominated for Best Film by the NBR, the last two slots, in my opinion, are fairly open season. Once the WGA announces their nominees, we'll have a much clearer picture.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Manchester by the Sea (Kenneth Lonergan)
2. Moonlight (Barry Jenkins and Tarrell Alvin McCraney)
3. The Lobster (Yorgos Lanthimos and Efthymis Filippou)
4. La La Land (Damien Chazelle)
5. Hell or High Water (Taylor Sheridan)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Jackie (Noah Oppenheim)
7. 20th Century Women (Mike Mills)
8. Loving (Jeff Nichols)
9. Zootopia (Byron Howard, Jared Bush, Rich Moore, Josie Trinidad, Jim Reardon, Phil Johnston, Jennifer Lee)
10. Captain Fantastic (Matt Ross)
11. Toni Erdmann (Maren Ade)
12. Hail, Caesar! (Joel and Ethan Coen)
13. Everybody Wants Some!! (Richard Linklater)

Outside Shots:
14. Eye in the Sky (Guy Hibbert)
15. I, Daniel Blake (Paul Laverty)
16. Paterson (Jim Jarmusch)
17. American Honey (Andrea Arnold)
18. Cafe Society (Woody Allen)


Best Supporting Actress

We're in the big leagues, folks. The top three slots of this category are pretty safely locked up - Michelle Williams has one movie-stealing scene at the end of Manchester by the Sea that has been making waves with critics (she's also a three-time Oscar nominee already), Naomie Harris is one of about a dozen note-perfect performances as a drug addicted mother in Moonlight, and Paramount is following in the footsteps of The Danish Girl and Carol last year committing category fraud by campaigning clearly leading ladies as supporting characters (although it's a little more understandable this year, as Best Actress is incredibly tough) with Viola Davis playing opposite Denzel in the 1950s-set racial drama Fences.

The two most likely to me from there are Nicole Kidman for Lion, an indie drama about an Indian orphan that is on everyone's Oscar guess list despite lukewarm reviews and absolutely no representation with critics circles so far, with her performance being the only thing it seems anyone is willing to consistently praise this film for, and Janelle Monae for Hidden Figures. All of this is hinging on my hunch that Hidden Figures will be a commercial hit and enough of a crowd-pleaser to be a Best Picture threat. If Moonlight proves too outre, it would be a decent avenue for staving off #OscarsSoWhite criticisms for a third year in a row. That, and Monae is a talented performer that's having a successful year, and she's the sassiest of the women by the look of the trailers.

Notably, though, the frontrunner among critics circles so far has been Lily Gladstone for Certain Women. I've heard no buzz about this film beyond its great reception, but especially if SAG goes for her, she might be a surprise nominee. The remaining choices are really rather lightweight, so it seems like a six-way race to me.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Viola Davis (Fences)
2. Michelle Williams (Manchester by the Sea)
3. Naomie Harris (Moonlight)
4. Nicole Kidman (Lion)
5. Janelle Monae (Hidden Figures)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Lily Gladstone (Certain Women)
7. Greta Gerwig (20th Century Women)
8. Felicity Jones (A Monster Calls)
9. Molly Shannon (Other People)
10. Lupita Nyong'o (Queen of Katwe)

Outside Shots:
11. Helen Mirren (Eye in the Sky)
12. Margo Martindale (The Hollars)
13. Rachel Weisz (The Light Between Oceans)
14. Teresa Palmer (Hacksaw Ridge)


Best Supporting Actor

As is typical with this category, this year's Best Supporting Actor race is all over the damn place. Mahershala Ali and Lucas Hedges seem to be the only true locks, but Jeff Bridges has a real shot with Hell or High Water (a very unexpected but deserved nod if it is one) after an impressive presence among critics and with the NBR. Liam Neeson is a safe bet for Silence (although the LAFCA gave the runner-up award to a Japanese actor in this film that may not have exposure until the movie is seen by regular audiences), and the Academy may want to reward Michael Shannon after snubbing him for 99 Homes - that is, if he gets another SAG nod this time around.

But outside of our two locks, it's mostly up in the air, and completely dependent on each actor's respective film's performance in other major categories. If the Academy likes Florence Foster Jenkins more than most people are expecting them to, expect Hugh Grant to be a very safe bet.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Mahershala Ali (Moonlight)
2. Lucas Hedges (Manchester by the Sea)
3. Jeff Bridges (Hell or High Water)
4. Liam Neeson (Silence)
5. Michael Shannon (Nocturnal Animals)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Hugh Grant (Florence Foster Jenkins)
7. Ben Foster (Hell or High Water)
8. Stephen Henderson (Fences)
9. Mykelti Williamson (Fences)
10. Trevante Rhodes (Moonlight)
11. Andre Holland (Moonlight)
12. Ralph Fiennes (A Bigger Splash)
13. Dev Patel (Lion)

Outside Shots:
14. John Goodman (10 Cloverfield Lane)
15. Alden Ehrenreich (Hail, Caesar!)
16. Timothy Spall (Denial)
17. Kevin Costner (Hidden Figures)
18. Aaron Eckhart (Sully)
19. Peter Sarsgaard (Jackie)
20. Danny DeVito (The Comedian) 


Best Actress

Unlike most years, this year's Best Actress race is incredibly competitive.  There's almost twice as many potential nominees than there are nomination slots, and even some of the outside shots are not complete write-offs. The three locks, it seems, are Emma Stone, Natalie Portman, and Annette Bening, and from then on there are almost a dozen reasonable potential matchups for the bottom two slots. The most likely in mind are Isabelle Huppert, who is the biggest winner in critics circles so far, and Amy Adams for Arrival, just based on the goodwill for it. If Florence hits Oscar voters where they live, Streep is a strong potential spoiler, and Negga, Henson, and Chastain are likable performers whose respective films rest on their shoulders.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Emma Stone (La La Land)
2. Natalie Portman (Jackie)
3. Annette Bening (20th Century Women)
4. Isabelle Huppert (Elle)
5. Amy Adams (Arrival)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Ruth Negga (Loving)
7. Meryl Streep (Florence Foster Jenkins)
8. Jessica Chastain (Miss Sloane)
9. Taraji P. Henson (Hidden Figures)
10. Jennifer Lawrence (Passengers)

Outside Shots:
11. Hailee Steinfeld (The Edge of Seventeen)
12. Rachel Weisz (Denial)
13. Marion Cotillard (Allied)
14. Sally Field (Hello, My Name is Doris)
15. Kate Beckinsale (Love & Friendship)
16. Rebecca Hall (Christine)
17. Sasha Lane (American Honey)
18. Susan Sarandon (The Meddler)


Best Actor

A rather lukewarm year for this category (the second such in a row), though that's not to say there are no great performances and are not many to choose from. Like Best Actress, we have three locks in my opinion - Casey Affleck (the favorite to win), Denzel Washington (one of few things said to truly shine about this film), and Tom Hanks (as a matter of career honors and makeup for Captain Phillips snub). I'm guessing Gosling is in because La La Land will be taking home many nominations most likely (and generally speaking, when the Academy really likes you, they start handing you nominations in categories no one even expected - think Tom Hardy for The Revenant last year). My fifth slot has Andrew Garfield for either Hacksaw Ridge or Silence, the former because I think that film's gonna get more nods than expected, or the latter if the Academy really loves it. 

That slot could be filled by a small numbers of legitimate threats, though it's a six-way race at most before getting to some outside shots. 

Predicted Nominees:
1. Casey Affleck (Manchester by the Sea)
2. Denzel Washington (Fences)
3. Tom Hanks (Sully)
4. Ryan Gosling (La La Land)
5. Andrew Garfield (Hacksaw Ridge or Silence)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Joel Edgerton (Loving)
7. Viggo Mortensen (Captain Fantastic)
8. Michael Keaton (The Founder)
9. Adam Driver (Paterson)
10. Matthew McConaughey (Gold)

Outside Shots:
11. Jake Gyllenhaal (Nocturnal Animals)
12. Ben Affleck (Live by Night)
13. Mark Wahlberg (Patriots Day)
14. Colin Farrell (The Lobster)
15. Robert DeNiro (The Comedian)


Best Director

In my estimation, we only have two true locks for nominations here - Barry Jenkins for Moonlight and Damien Chazelle for La La Land, the two frontrunners to win Best Picture at this point. Scorsese is a frequent favorite who gets nominated even for his less tight work, so a nod for him for Silence is likely, especially if it's as great as he's built it up to be. While Manchester is mostly an actors' piece, the film does have well-directed scenes in spades, and it's incredibly well-liked (its Best Picture win with the NBR is not nothing), so Lonergan could snatch a nomination. I personally think Denis Villenuve should and will get a nod for his work on Arrival, but there's a good case to be made as to why that's not happening.

Washington is an outside shot for Fences for a few reasons. For one, he's already nominated in the acting category. Second, the actors are the main points of praise for that film. Third, I don't think Fences has churned up enough genuine buzz outside of its performances and will be hitting theaters rather late, so I don't find it a particular Best Picture threat, and thus don't expect it to show up here. Mel Gibson and Pablo Larrain are the only true threats beyond that, most of the rest of the possibilities being outside shots.

Predicted Nominees:
1. Damien Chazelle (La La Land)
2. Barry Jenkins (Moonlight)
3. Martin Scorsese (Silence)
4. Kenneth Lonergan (Manchester by the Sea)
5. Denis Villeneuve (Arrival)

Potential Spoilers:
6. Mel Gibson (Hacksaw Ridge)
7. Denzel Washington (Fences)
8. Pablo Larrain (Jackie)

Outside Shots:
9. Jeff Nichols (Loving)
10. David Mackenzie (Hell or High Water)
11. Garth Davis (Lion)
12. Clint Eastwood (Sully)
13. Ben Affleck (Live by Night)
14. Tom Ford (Nocturnal Animals)


Best Picture

For those unaware, Best Picture can have between 5 and 10 nominations. It usually lands around eight, but I'm going nine in my guesses for now.

Our three definite locks are La La Land, Moonlight, and Manchester by the Sea, who have split Best Picture votes across precursor awards thus far, with La La Land having a slight edge. Silence, Arrival, and Jackie are all pretty safe bets in my opinion, but Sully, Hell or High Water, and Hacksaw Ridge all have good potential to gain traction as well. Hidden Figures would cap off a possible 10-film roster, with a few fairly lightweight films having a small chance to spoil that spot. Also, it's probably nothing, but the nomination of Patriots Day for Best Picture by NBR makes me think it might be a movie to keep an eye on for a possible late-period upset.

Locks:
1. La La Land
2. Moonlight
3. Manchester by the Sea

Other Possible Nominations:
4. Silence
5. Arrival
6. Jackie
7. Sully
8. Hacksaw Ridge
9. Hell or High Water

Possible Tenth Nominations:
10. Hidden Figures
11. 20th Century Women
12. Live by Night

Outside Shots:
13. Patriots Day
14. Zootopia
15. The Lobster
16. The Founder
17. Elle
18. Toni Erdmann
19. Florence Foster Jenkins
20. A Monster Calls
21. Hail, Caesar!
22. The Jungle Book
23. Allied

There you have it, folks - my first set of predictions for the 2017 Oscar nominations, described in way too much depth. Stay tuned for my following updates to this list, as well as for reviews of the following films:

- Moana
- La La Land
- Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

December 6, 2016

"Manchester by the Sea" Review

Manchester by the Sea is a drama film directed and written by Kenneth Lonergan and starring Casey Affleck, Lucas Hedges, Michelle Williams, Kyle Chandler, and Matthew Broderick for a hot second. Affleck plays Lee, a cagey, sardonic drunk handyman in Boston who has been hardened by a devastating past. Lee's life starts to suck even more when his brother Joe dies, and Joe's son Patrick (Hedges) is unexpectedly left in his care, and so begins two and a half hours of being incredibly upset.

I'm going to disappoint a ton of people with this review. Manchester by the Sea has gotten unanimously amazing reviews ever since it premiered at Sundance almost a year ago. And it's not like with something like Finding Dory when its crazily high Rotten Tomatoes score is the product of just across-the-board mild approval; this has been called the greatest film of the year by numerous critics, and recently, the National Board of Review. And I gotta say, I'm not much of a fan. That's not a sentiment I'm proud to have either - I really wanted to love this movie, and I don't even think it's not good. But there was something missing.

To stop myself from talking myself into a hole, I want to stress that there is a lot to like about this film, chief among them being the performances. If you've paid attention the reception of this movie you've probably heard that Casey Affleck gives a performance that is one of the best American cinema has had to offer in years, and it's a very earned point of praise. Affleck's character is somehow eminently likable despite being a total asshole. He's tasked to walk a very tricky tightrope trying to keep the audience mostly on his side throughout the story, and he does so with aplomb. The rest of the cast is suitably great as well - Lucas Hedges is incredibly convincing and charming as Patrick, and Michelle Williams (who I believe is being over-hyped in trailers and on posters even though she legitimately only has about 8 minutes of screen time) sort of steals the entire third act with a very emotional scene where she really shows off her talents.

It's not all just weeping and yelling either, though there is a lot of it, like any Oscar-hopeful family drama. These actors, and in a lot of ways Lonergan's screenplay, nail the subtleties of their characters and situations, and a lot of the film is actually quite funny, in a very dark way. Having tangential knowledge of Lonergan's past work in film and theater, I'm aware that his M.O. is sort of "kitchen sink realism", and it shows in Manchester. Many scenes in this film are very memorable either for their intense emotion (though I notably never found myself tearing up at any point, surprisingly) or their surprising wit, especially scenes revolving around Patrick, and most of them feel like real life, a sentiment echoed about this film by many a critic.

However, I think it's almost to the film's detriment. Don't get me wrong; I am usually a huge fan of pessimistic, depressing, darkly funny, grounded, slow-burning films where nothing happens and the lesson is that life sucks and problems are never completely solved, and this film fully embodies all of those qualities. Yet for some reason, there was just something not clicking for me with this film. I can tell you about almost a dozen scenes from this film that I genuinely loved, and everything from its message to its fairly pitch-perfect visual presentation of a New England coastal town is definitely up my alley. As a whole, though, I felt the film was underwhelming. I didn't feel like I'd witnessed an entire fine-tuned single work made up of connected parts, but rather a series of disjointed upsetting slices of life that were all interesting in their own right. I'm not too sure how to articulate it beyond that.

I also have just never found Lonergan to be an intriguing art-maker. While this movie has some incredible realism, it does at times feel like a working class people story as told by a rich New York playwright. The characters are fleshed out and well-acted, but they still feel like archetypes. And especially with the film's overbearing and unnecessary orchestral score during the most emotional scenes (I personally feel many of the scenes would've worked better with silence) and the cloying nature of most of its marketing, I had this feeling that most of the film's biggest emotions weren't completely genuine. I can't quite put my finger on why, but I never saw past the veneer of it being an Oscar-hopeful drama about sad people written by a very confident and thoughtful Artiste who really wanted me to cry. It doesn't all feel manipulative, but it did at times.

And while, as I said, I love a good nihilist story where a lot of loose ends are never tied up in the name of dispelling some hard truths about the unforgiving nature of the universe upon mankind, this film left me feeling sort of lost and unsatisfied. When the film faded to black and the credits rolled, I was really taken aback and felt like the meaning of everything I'd watched just was never made clear. I don't need subtext spoonfed to me, but I didn't even really see the bowl in this situation. Notably, that is exactly how our main characters feel at the end of the film, so perhaps this disappointment with everything not making sense is how I'm supposed to feel. Maybe this movie really is brilliant and I'm just stupid. I'm open to and okay with this possibility.

Overall, while I don't think I'll watch it again for a long time, I recommend Manchester by the Sea. If you think you're gonna love it, you probably will. I'm definitely the odd one out here. It's by no means poorly done - it has a number of amazing performances and a script filled with delightful touches that unfortunately didn't add up to much for me. If you parse your expectations like I didn't, you'll probably really enjoy it. I'm sure I'm gonna get a lot of flak for giving Manchester by the Sea a lower rating than I gave Sausage Party (although upon thinking about it more I've retroactively reduced my rating of that film to a B-), but hey, it's how I feel.

Grade: B

(Stay tuned very soon for my first Oscar predictions)

November 29, 2016

"Arrival" Review

 Arrival is a sci-fi mystery drama thriller film directed by Denis Villeneuve, written by Eric Heisserer from the short story "The Story of Your Life" by Ted Chiang, and starring Amy Adams, Jeremy Renner, Forest Whitaker, and Michael Stuhlbarg. The film follows linguistics professor and former government translator Louise Banks (Adams), who is recruited by a US government official (Whitaker) to attempt to translate the conversations with an alien race who have positioned twelve ominous monolithic "shell" spacecraft at different landing points across the globe, including one in a field in Montana, to try to interpret whether they have visited Earth for peaceful or hostile purposes. What follows from Louise learning their written language while trying to subvert any aggression on the part of foreign governments is something I'll leave you to find out for yourself. With Arrival, what begins as a perfectly well-realized and thought-provoking foray into modern science fiction filmmaking soon turns into an emotional, enthralling mindfuck whose believability and effectiveness can be credited primarily to the realization of the concepts in Chiang's brilliant short story by Eric Heisserer, and the performance of Amy Adams.

On a technical level, Arrival is a consistently impressive work. Cinematographer Bradford Young utilizes director Denis Villeneuve's penchant for heady examinations of humanity being photographed in incredibly naturalistic ways that Roger Deakins perfected in Prisoners and Sicario, and while this is by no means Villeneuve's best-shot film, Young's camerawork is still sumptuous and even breathtaking at times, particularly a sweeping reveal shot of the alien spacecraft and the military base camp surrounding it toward the beginning. Johann Johannson's ominous score packs an emotional punch, especially when the film takes a turn for the surreal.

Heisserer's script and Villeneuve's direction are also carried out in a way that emphasizes grounded realism mostly to the film's best ability. Villeneuve has a particular talent for making his twists and tension feel earned and easily found crawling under the viewer's skin by setting up his worlds and characters in very grounded and believable ways. The story's handling of the minute details, both in feeling and in action, of an alien invasion on Earth is believable enough that we accept with open arms the times in the story that the film becomes more surreal and mind-bending, and also begins to bring up its more challenging concepts. The scenes at the beginning of the film of the immediate aftermath of the landing is one of the most memorable and effective in the film for me, as are some of the developments in the months following, such as news of a cult group lighting their compound on fire in a case of mass suicide in response to the aliens, and the rantings of a right-wing anti-government conspiracy theorist on talk radio blaming the problem on the president. These details are mostly relegated to the background, and indeed only serve as added bonuses in the story of Louise, but they're noticeable and make the world of Arrival seem that much more authentic.

This isn't to say the film doesn't have its moments of breaking from believability, oddly enough very few of them having to do with aliens. Not to spoil anything, but there's one scene involving the actions of a few unnamed soldiers that doesn't make a whole lot of sense and is sort of improperly built up, and the film does have its share of lines that cross into the realm of moderate cheese ("What happens now?" "They arrive."). These aren't film-ruining problems, but when the rest of the story and technical aspects of the film make the world so lusciously believable, they are noticeable. Such issues are relatively few and far between, though, and the script, on a thematic and tonal level, is rather airtight.

The emotional complexity of Amy Adams's performance, which is one of the very best of her impressive career, couples with the most brilliant aspects of Heisserer's script to create a sci-fi filmgoing experience that's rich and thought-provoking, even dipping its toes into the realm of mind-bending toward the end of its second act. Arrival really is a film about Louise and about communication, and while the film's marketing may not give you that idea, the script is filled with several slyly hidden and subtle hints from the very start of the film to the themes and concepts that unfold following the revelation of the film's slow-burning twist. And not to be that guy all the time, but at its core, the film's message, which is rather simple but is unfolded in an original, complex, and interesting way, is one that I feel is rather timely and important - that is, it is a film about the importance of diplomacy and communication. In a very bizarre and trippy way, Arrival is the story of a woman teaching the world how to try and understand foreign ways of thinking in order to better communicate for the betterment of both parties rather than initial hostility at anything different. I know this election season has a brutal one so the politicization of anything is particularly likely to flare up emotions right now, but art doesn't exist in a vacuum and I found the movie's underlying message to be refreshing and appropriate for the current political climate.

Overall, Arrival is sort of the stuff of sci-fi classics. I can easily see it sitting up with the likes of Close Encounters of the Third Kind or 2001: A Space Odyssey, science fiction that is thoughtful and challenging, but ultimately gets to the core essences of humanity and examines them through fantastical, yet scarily plausible, scenarios. It explores communication, perception, and problem solving in such a fascinating way that I feel bad keeping you in the dark on how it does - it makes a lot of my praises sound very vague and odd, but I truly want you to unpack this movie step by step as you watch it like I did. Especially if you're unfamiliar with the short story as I was, watching Arrival is like an engrossing puzzle. Is it straightforward? Yes. Does that make it any less engaging? Absolutely not.

And if you'd rather bypass all that, you'll still get an entertaining and intriguing sci-fi story (though, be warned, one that is not filled with action or disaster sequences - spoilers?), a terrific performance from Amy Adams, and some beautiful camerawork and a haunting musical score. Ex Machina - and to a lesser extent Interstellar - now have company as thinking man's sci-fi movies of this generation.

Grade: A

November 22, 2016

"Moonlight" Review

Moonlight is an independent drama film directed and written by Barry Jenkins from a story by Tarrell Alvin McCraney. It stars Trevante Rhodes, Ashton Sanders, Alex Hibbert, Andre Holland, Jharrel Jerome, Jaden Piner, Naomie Harris, Mahershala Ali, and Janelle Monae. Told in three distinct parts, the film highlights three moments in the life of Chiron, a gay black man living in a rough neighborhood of Miami, during his childhood, adolescence, and young adulthood. Through these snapshots, we see the quiet and subdued Chiron attempt to make connections with his best friend Kevin, his drug-addicted mother (Harris), and a kind trap couple that takes him under their wing (Ali, Monae). What follows is a poignant examination of the human condition virtually peerless in modern cinema.

I kind of don't know where to start with this film, which just brims with emotional complexity from its structural simplicity. Evoking the neo-realism of 1960s Italian cinema for a decidedly postmodern audience, there really is no other film like Moonlight. This film has had praise dumped on it since its premiere, and I'll only be adding to it. I've only seen it once, but I can't think of a single flaw.

To get the surface level elements out of the way, the film is stunning from a technical standpoint. Cinematographer James Laxton shoots much of the movie with a very shallow depth of field, at times with only a character's face being in focus, creating a feeling of intense intimacy. Editors Joi McMillon and Nat Sanders string together Chiron's story in a way that lets the film move breezily and quietly, and the result is nothing short of mesmerizing. The way the images and scenes effortlessly ebb and flow together make the experience of watching Moonlight a captivating and engaging one to say the least. On top of that, every performance - and I mean every performance - in the film is absolutely terrific, including a number of child and teen performances, which is itself a major accomplishment. Ali, Harris, Rhodes, Holland, Monae, and Sanders are the standout performances, though it really is impossible to single any one actor out, as they all breathe incredible life into complex, impeccably wrought characters.

And the characters and their interactions with each other, and specifically their interactions with Chiron, is the thread that binds the film's story together. One of the essential aspects of great screenwriting is avoiding cliche. Moonlight not only avoids the cliches and stereotypes you might expect to see in an Oscar-campaigning indie film about a gay black man living among gangsters and drug slingers; it ventures inside each of them and actively dismantles them. It not only asks you to leave behind your assumptions and preconceptions of the experiences of black people, LGBT people, drug dealers, drug addicts, men, boys, single mothers, etc.; it confronts those preconceptions and shatters them, revealing the complex humanity in each of these archetypes too rarely offered honest portrayal in American cinema.

Through its unconventional all-violin score to its striking and intimate camerawork to its breathlessly personal and compassionate screenplay, Moonlight tells a story that strips away its characters' superficial identity signifiers and instead presents us human beings whose experiences have shaped them over generations. Chiron encounters many of the same people at the three different points in his life shown in the film, and with each there is growth, conflict, and forgiveness. Culminating in his final words of confession to a longtime childhood friend, we learn through Chiron's experiences that no matter the societal labels, our most important commonality as human beings is that we strive for connection and understanding amid feelings of isolation and pressure to live up to the expectations of either society or those around us, whether relating to preconceived notions of masculinity, sexuality, or more simply what makes someone a good person, or what it means to love someone, to forgive someone.

In a way, Moonlight is everything we go to the movies for - to understand each other, to feel each other's experiences, to ache with one another, to try to find solace in the fact that we are not alone in feeling pain, loneliness, or the pressure of creating a life for ourselves. Moonlight strips down its characters' stereotypical archetypes to reveal their humanity, urgently challenging us to see through color, sexuality, social status, physical appearance, or walk of life, accept those differences, and really, truly feel for one another and connect with one another for the good of all of us. And it does so in a way that is unique, original, captivating, uplifting, poignant, and almost spiritual.

Moonlight is a soulful, brilliant, and I would say essential film. In a time where empathy and recognition of common humanity is often blockaded by matters of identity, Moonlight is a refreshing take on that theme from an uncommon voice. But don't think that simple politics explain why this film is so great - Moonlight's tale of the astonishing power and necessity of human connection and the eternal struggle to be accepted and understood is a timeless one. Roger Ebert once said that movies are "a machine that generates empathy". Moonlight is the purest incarnation of that machine I've seen in a long, long time.

Grade: A+

"The Edge of Seventeen" Review

The Edge of Seventeen is a coming of age comedy-drama film directed and written by Kelly Fremon Craig and starring Hailee Steinfeld, Woody Harrelson, Kyra Sedgwick, Haley Lu Richardson, Blake Jenner, and Hayden Szeto. Steinfeld plays 17-year-old Nadine, who's always been difficult and a bit of a loner, taking solace only in her friend Krista (Richardson), especially after a family tragedy at the end of middle school. Nadine's life begins to fall further apart, however, when Krista hooks up with and later begins dating her confident, attractive older brother (Jenner). Nadine attempts to navigate this situation alongside her sardonic history teacher (Harrelson) and an awkward boy who has a crush on her (Szeto), all while dealing with the regular trappings of being an angsty teenager.

This film was originally titled Besties, and if you're like me, you'd probably read that title and my synopsis and roll your eyes a bit, thinking that there are a million movies telling the story of The Edge of Seventeen. And you'd be right. Where you'd be wrong, however, is assuming that this film is generic, unsurprising, or not worthy of your time. I had hints of that feeling when I saw the first trailers for this film. To my surprise, The Edge of Seventeen ended up being one of the most enjoyable movies I've seen this year, and perhaps one of the best coming of age movies of this generation. I mean it.

Let's enumerate the negatives first, because there are very few. The Edge of Seventeen is a teen dramedy about growing up and being an angsty bitch and experiencing your adolescent sexual awakening, and it hits all of the requisite notes of the genre and doesn't offer many surprises on a narrative level, insofar as that I was able to guess where the story was going at basically any turn. While the film largely avoids cliches and gaps in reality, two observations I made that took me out of it at times were the fact that Woody Harrelson's teacher character would definitely be fired for saying the things he says to Nadine, and that a girl as beautiful as Hailee Steinfeld would never have trouble convincing boys to have sex with her in any American high school I can think of. These are the only primary points at which the film enters a world of fiction.

Beyond that, though, The Edge of Seventeen works so well because of its believability and authenticity, which is owed to the well-rounded characters that Kelly Fremon Craig creates and the performances of the actors portraying them, especially Harrelson and Steinfeld. This is a rare R-rated coming of age film, and the movie revels in it. Sexuality is confronted frankly and unabashedly, and our main characters are vulgar, politically incorrect, and often legitimately shitty people to each other. And it all feels authentic and honest, a quality every coming of age film strives for. The film doesn't cheekily and obviously poke fun at genre tropes while embracing them in execution like many entries in the genre of late. The Edge of Seventeen doesn't care if you've heard this kind of story before; it prefers instead to tell it with honesty, personality, and a population of three-dimensional characters.

Nadine is not an angsty teenager for the sake of it. Her experiences shape her, though she prefers to see those experiences through an immature, sarcastic lens. What's refreshing about the film is how it doesn't settle for simplicity in exploring the relationships between its characters. This isn't a story of a girl who is outcast for no reason and thrown into bad situation after bad situation as she pleads for mercy, being the only teenager who understands the world - in fact, that's what Nadine would want it to be. Instead, Nadine is simply thrust into an existence rife with unfortunate experiences, the effects of which are exacerbated by her own personal flaws and the flaws of those around her. That's what makes the story and characters in The Edge of Seventeen feel so fresh. No one's a good guy or bad guy; they're people who make mistakes and struggle to come back from them. You either know or are someone in this movie. It sounds simple enough, but you'd be surprised how hard many similar movies find it to get it just right. This is truly the Goldilocks zone of coming of age movies.

And, again, not to minimize the great work from Craig (in her directorial debut, by the way), but this can really be owed to the charm and talent of the cast, especially Hailee Steinfeld. She absolutely carries the film, pulling the audience gracefully and tactfully through the film's many tonal shifts, making Nadine sympathetic, bitchy, or just plain goofy whenever needed. Steinfeld's impressive command of her part in Craig's script gives Nadine even further emotional complexity, culminating most notably in a tearful confession scene during the film's climax that had me legitimately teary-eyed.

The Edge of Seventeen is smart, funny, sweet, and uplifting. It's a story about the very real tendency of adolescents to assume they are alone in their pain in life, and that nobody else gets it. This film is a reminder of the universality of the awkwardness, sadness, isolation, and self-consciousness of the adolescent experience, and that each individual is ultimately responsible for their method of tackling life's numerous obstacles. It's an incredibly refreshing addition to a very crowded genre, and an exciting leap forward for a newcomer filmmaker. It's fairly by-the-numbers as far as this type of stories go, but if anything, The Edge of Seventeen is testament to how far any story can be taken with a talented cast, well-written characters, and an abundance of charm and authenticity.

Grade: A-

November 5, 2016

"Doctor Strange" Review

Doctor Strange is a superhero fantasy action film directed by Scott Derrickson, written by Derrickson, C. Robert Cargill, and Jon Spaihts, and starring Benedict Cumberbatch, Tilda Swinton, Mads Mikkelsen, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Rachel McAdams, and Benedict Wong. It's based on the Marvel comics character and is the 468th film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Now that the Earth-based (Avengers, Captain America, Iron Man) and space-based (Guardians of the Galaxy) aspects of the MCU have been established, Doctor Strange continues Thor's delving into the mystical realm, this time revolving around Eastern mysticism instead of Norse mythology. The movie itself follows Steven Strange (Cumberbatch), a successful, arrogant neurosurgeon who suffers a debilitating car crash that leaves him in only marginal control of his hands, effectively ending his entire career. After Western medicine fails him, he travels to Nepal to attempt a sort of healing possible only through the spiritual realm, and is introduced to the Ancient One (Swinton), who leads a spiritual resistance against a rogue ex-student of hers (Mikkelsen), who is bent on enveloping the natural world in the dark realm, an existence outside of time where life is eternal, but miserable.

Doctor Strange is, appropriately, probably the strangest Marvel film thus far in terms of subject matter. Yes, Guardians had a talking tree and raccoon and was fairly innovative in terms of tone when it comes to superhero films, but Strange decidedly goes for a more fantastical setting and tone than any previous Marvel film to date. And it gets extra points for embracing that and running with it to entertaining degrees. What remains is an exceptionally entertaining, if still a bit formulaic, Marvel movie. But don't write it off from that sentiment alone.

Unsurprisingly, Benedict Cumberbatch does a wonderful job as the character Strange, who is almost grossly arrogant and callous to his girlfriend (McAdams) in the film's opening scenes, and yet somehow manages to come off as likable and a genuine hero to root for. McAdams, Ejiofor, and Swinton all deliver superlative performances as well, elevating their characters into the realm of the third dimension beyond the typical cookie-cutter action flick characters they could've been. Mads Mikkelsen does a great job as the villain whose name escapes me, but as the first clause of this sentence might have tipped you off to, the villain is unfortunately under-written, under-developed, and Mikkelsen's acting chops mostly remain untapped. His scenes are effective, but they are few and far between.

In regards to the action and spectacle, I actually preferred the treatment of these elements to this year's other Marvel outing, Captain America: Civil War, mostly for choosing to be more visually creative than most Marvel films (as well as having the first Marvel musical score, written by Michael Giacchino, that I actually actively wanted to listen to later). While Derrickson's direction of the hand-to-hand combat leaves a lot to be desired (if someone with more of a hold on effective martial arts fight choreography had helmed this film, it could have had some of the most enthralling action scenes in the MCU), the setpieces for the action are stupendous. Even if not as innovatively shot or involving as they could've been, each action sequence makes use of new developments of the world in the film, and are creative and entertaining, especially a fight taking place between two spirits in a doctor's office and one involving time moving backwards around our characters.

And the visual effects are bonkers - if it weren't for The Jungle Book this year, I'd give Doctor Strange the Best Visual Effects Oscar. Some of Doctor Strange's most entertaining sequences involve kaleidoscopes of bizarre imagery straight out of an acid trip, tesseracts, and shapes folding in on themselves as the characters' spirits and minds hop across dimensions. From folding New York City streets into cubes to trapping characters inside of walls as buildings reconstruct themselves in backwards-moving time, computer-generated imagery is used as it should be in Doctor Strange - to create dazzling, mind-bending images that are truly transporting and impossible in the natural world.

What mostly bogs down Doctor Strange is the fact that this is yet another superhero origin story, and it hits all those notes as it should. The screenplay is competently written, with plenty of set-ups and payoffs, some effective humor sprinkled throughout, and my second-favorite ending of any Marvel movie thus far (the first being Civil War, so it's nice to see Marvel is beginning to branch out beyond "villain creates giant glowing thing in the sky to destroy a city"). I actually think the movie should've gone on about 20 minutes longer. Strange's training in the mystical arts is largely skipped over, and we don't get to see much of an evolution of him as a sorcerer. He goes from being unable to doing basic tasks to being one of the most gifted students in what is told to us to be several months, but in reality is only about 5 minutes of screen time. Beyond that, the film mostly plays by the numbers of any other superhero origin story, so if you're completely sick of those, you may not have a lot of fun with this film. Luckily, the mystic aspect keeps the film mostly fresh, even if its screenplay isn't as tight, subtextual, or carefully crafted as Civil War's.

I feel like I'm being overly harsh when I really enjoyed this movie. Trust me, being a well-done superhero origin story is not nothing, and this film has plenty of wonderful things going for it. In the end, Doctor Strange is visually resplendent, well-acted, and satisfying middle-ground addition to the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It doesn't reinvent the wheel as far as superhero film formula, but it has just enough surface-level shake-ups to keep me invested in Marvel's crazy decade-long crossover mania. I look forward to seeing Strange and Tony Stark trading snarky quips in the upcoming Avengers movie.

Grade: B+

October 23, 2016

"Jackie" Review

Jackie is a biographical historical drama film directed by Chilean filmmaker Pablo Larrain, written by Noah Oppenheim, and starring Natalie Portman, Peter Sarsgaard, Greta Gerwig, Billy Crudup, Max Casella, and John Hurt. Portman plays First Lady Jackie Kennedy, wife of President John F. Kennedy, and the film follows the First Lady reeling after the assassination of her husband in Dallas in 1963. Told through two framing devices of her interview with a reporter (Crudup) in the weeks following the assassination as well as her televised tour of the refurbished White House in 1962, we follow Jackie primarily as she struggles to put together Jack's funeral procession, as well as make sense of her life and the state of the country following the death of her husband.

I had the pleasure of seeing this movie at the Philadelphia Film Festival this week on the pretense of Natalie Portman's performance being lauded by numerous critics as Oscar-worthy. And her performance is absolutely outstanding for sure, and I'll talk about that, but don't be fooled into thinking that this film is simply an actress vehicle or a fluffy Oscar-baiting period piece. This is an intelligent, alluring, intense, poetic, and heartbreaking portrait of an American cultural icon that is one of few films of this year that I'd deem a "must-see".

Let's get the obvious out of the way. Natalie Portman delivers the performance of her career as Jackie Kennedy. Beyond being a pitch-perfect recreation of her soft, airy, almost princess-like voice and demeanor, Portman disappears into Jackie, giving uncommon dimension to a monolithic historical figure. The issue with period pieces revolving around well-known historical figures is that these people tend to enter a sort of mythology, and it's easy to simply cast lookalike actors to play to the cultural conceptions of said figures without humanizing them beyond a teary monologue. Portman, and the film at large, achieve the rare feat of presenting Jackie as a human with a complex story, one that just happens to be enveloped by the larger story of American politics. This is bolstered by Oppenheim's screenplay (which I'll talk about toward the end), but Portman holds a lot of responsibility for the film's emotional power and the intrigue into a well-worn story, bringing levels of depth to an icon of American history with such poise and charisma unseen since Daniel Day-Lewis in Lincoln - yes, she's that good. The supporting cast holds up terrifically as well, specifically Peter Sarsgaard as Bobby Kennedy, but make no mistake; this is Natalie's movie.

Natalie Portman was lucky, however, to be acting within such a marvelously crafted movie helmed by a brilliant filmmaker. The film, running at a brisk 90-odd minutes, moves like music through its somewhat nonlinear storyline, with a consistent feeling of unease, concocted primarily through Mica Levi's piercing musical score and Stephane Fontaine's intense camerawork. As a story operating mostly behind the scenes of a very public and heavily examined event, Larrain and his creative crew use the iconic elements of the Kennedys - the motorcade, the pink Chanel suit, etc. - to effective ends.

The film is entirely self-aware of the magnitude of its subjects, and uses them not to simply evoke thoughts of "remember this?" for those who may recognize them, but as subtle methods of engagement, creating a sort of intertextuality with real-life American history. No need for explanation or inclusion of iconic events or symbols for the sake of reminding us of the period, but instead to flare up feelings within the audience, often without having to utter a single word about them. It presents these familiar icons of the time so that it may then rip apart our perceptions of them and examine them in a new, and often decidedly uncomfortable, light, literally soaking the idyllic and the beautiful in blood, forcing the audience, as well as Jackie, to reconsider their previously held notions about the people, places, and things typically associated with a just world and a great America that we all thought we knew.

Which brings me to the greatest surprise of this film for me, which is the brilliance of Noah Oppenheim's script. Jackie is not a mere presentation of Jacqueline Kennedy, but a layered and thoughtful character study. And it even goes deeper than an examination of just Jackie, going so far as to ponder the nature of America in general. In many ways, the Kennedys were sort of the swan song of the classical view of America, where presidents, however clearly orchestrated or evidently sleazy, were honorable men of immense stature and idolization, almost to the point of appearing mythical. Jackie, thrust into a life of scrutiny and chaos through her marriage to Jack, has an infatuation with this view of classical America and indeed falls for the facade. She sees her husband as the same myth as the public sees him, as a final bearer of "Camelot", and wants to honor it thusly with a much-publicized restoration of the White House to include paintings and artifacts of historical significance, and to maximize the theatricality of her husband's funeral procession. This involves her often tricking herself into believing that all of this is warranted for her husband's greatness as both man and president, but at some point having to admit to herself that it is an ultimate exercise in vanity.

The film uses America's most publicly popular family of the time to contemplate themes of perception vs. reality (this is most obvious in one of the film's few moments of levity wherein Jackie will describe something about her life or the assassination to the reporter with horrific detail, then immediately refuse to allow him to publish it because she "didn't say that"). Jackie's plea for a lasting Camelot, the idea that America was great and that there is divine purpose to even the greatest of tragedies that will ultimately lead to success and happiness, is not condemned by the film as mere frivolity, but rather as something of a good-natured sham. Jackie claims at one point that her demands for a lavish funeral procession is simply "doing my job", referencing the old notion that the First Lady is there simply for show, to gussy up the public idea of the presidency and to keep up the old-fashioned idyllic perception of America, and her cognizance of this emerges in tandem with that of the reality of her husband's death and the probable meaninglessness of her life. In essence, the audience is forced to realize that their familiarity with the image of the Kennedys means nothing as to actually knowing anything about them or any of the image being true, and this realization is presented directly alongside Jackie's realization of the same fact regarding her own life. As Jackie washes away the glamour of her life, her husband, and America, so does the audience wash away the glamour of Jackie to see a truth that is ugly but, for once, honest.

For some reason, I don't feel like my analysis is doing this film or its complex themes much justice, but long story short, Jackie is an absolutely brilliant period drama and character study led by a terrific performance by Natalie Portman, packed with period detail and gorgeous cinematography, and bolstered by an uncommonly intelligent screenplay that examines public perception vs. reality through one of the most publicly scrutinized and widely watched events (and figures) in modern American history. In a political climate time and again punctuated by public forays into the private lives of larger-than-life people in power, Jackie is an intriguing look at its arguable genesis, showing the sudden and heartbreaking destruction of an old-fashioned, vain, but perhaps strangely necessary perception of inherent goodness and value in America and in life - the destruction of Camelot.

Jackie is one of the very, very best films of the year and I highly recommend seeing it. Its limited release in the US is December 2nd. I have no immediate qualms with it, and upon a second watch I may give it a perfect rating, but for now...

Grade: A