Florence Foster Jenkins is a biographical comedy-drama film directed by Stephen Frears and starring Meryl Streep, Hugh Grant, Simon Helberg, Nina Arianda, and Rebecca Ferguson. It tells the story of the legendary Carnegie Hall performance of Florence Foster Jenkins, a British New York socialite who loves music and performing but has an absolutely terrible singing voice, a fact that keeps her husband Mr. Bayfield (Grant) busy keeping the "scoffers and mockers" at bay.
I saw this movie with my mom, which is probably the best way to see it. This is by no means at all a work of groundbreaking, thought-provoking cinema, but Florence Foster Jenkins is such a delightful little confection of a movie that it's difficult not to recommend. In an age where online harassment by trolls of high-profile celebrities and public figures are getting extensive media attention and negativity is at the forefront of nearly every major news story, it's nice to have a movie strictly about a group of people working to the bone to keep someone else happy. But don't fret, fellow fans of sarcasm and pessimism, their creation of a sort of ridiculous socialite echo chamber, and the film's own tacit congratulating of it, are not met without ridicule. Frears welcomes your scoffing and mockery amid his film's own beguiling good nature.
Nicholas Martin's screenplay is not note-perfect here - the film does drag a bit toward the middle, and these performances are honestly a bit above their material. But if you're like me and are a fan of the kind of quips and crackly posh back-and-forthing that is so quintessentially British, you'll find yourself grinning through most of this movie's sequences. If you're also like me and enjoy period pieces featuring lavish sets and costumes, and hallmarks of the 1940s like swing dancing, tame and playful sexuality, and people somehow still looking distinguished and proper while being completely wasted, then this movie is once again a treat, especially once Florence starts flaunting her most ridiculous headpieces. Honestly, it's difficult to rag on this movie's flaws when there are just so many things to enjoy about it.
Like I said, the performances in this movie are honestly above their material, but this is anything but a negative point. Meryl Streep is reliably excellent - it's become almost an eye-roller to sing her praises as an actress, but she is a soon-to-be-20-time Oscar nominee for a reason. As someone who has time and again displayed actual substantial singing talent, her command of a character whose singing voice is impressively bad is remarkable. Few films get truly bad singing right - Florence's singing isn't just loud or slightly off-key. As one character puts it, "it defies medical science". Streep also adds considerable depth to her character, to the point that, even without the aide of brilliant makeup work, becomes another fully living person on the screen. Simon Helberg plays their jittery pianist in a way that could've been one-note, but ends up being almost as layered as it is entertaining.
Storied sub-par rom-com aficionado Hugh Grant nearly channels a Grant of another era by the name of Cary in his role as Florence's husband in an open relationship. Grant starts off screen-stealingly enough as a posh and peppy man that is the essence of the wartime elite, and soon grows into a fully realized character that adds to the humanity of the story. By the time Mr. Bayfield is explaining to us that he keeps Florence safe from the haters because he is devoted to her, we really feel and believe it, just as we do when Florence herself describes her love for music and performing.
In the end, Florence Foster Jenkins is not perfect, but it's an entertaining, funny, and sweet crowd-pleaser about courage, devotion, and just straight-up being nice. Streep and Grant are excellent in the lead roles, with a team of wonderful supporting players, some sure-handed direction from Stephen Frears, gorgeous costume work by Consolata Boyle, and reliably great swinging jazzy musical score from Alexandre Desplat to back them up in an otherwise somewhat loosely written story. The score may seem low, but this is a rather enthusiastic recommendation.
Grade: B+
August 25, 2016
"Hell or High Water" Review
Hell or High Water is a crime drama film directed by David Mackenzie, written by Taylor Sheridan (screenwriter of last year's Sicario), and starring Chris Pine, Ben Foster, Jeff Bridges, and Gil Birmingham. Pine and Foster play brothers living in west Texas who are on the brink of losing the family farm to the big banks. In an act of both desperation and revenge (depending on which of them you ask), the two resort to robbing various small-town banks around Texas and Oklahoma, Pine's character hoping to funnel it into a trust for his nephews, and Foster's character planning to blow it on casinos, booze, and hookers like a real man. Jeff Bridges and Gil Birmingham play a Texas sheriff and his accomplice, respectively, on the trail but always one step behind the two crooks in this modern pseudo-Western.
Between this, Sicario, and his work on the show Sons of Anarchy, Taylor Sheridan has a real interest and knack for writing modern-day crime. His greatest talent as well as his flaw as a screenwriter is that he is a pitch perfect scribe when it comes to observing and relaying said observations about modern America, but not so much at brilliantly expanding on them or offering any groundbreaking wisdom on them thematically. This film was described to me as a "dumbed down No Country for Old Men", which is fairly apt, if a little harsh. The movie isn't quite "dumb", just straightforward. Sheridan's presentations of post-financial crisis middle America, the casual racism of the South, and the general attitude of distrust and violence borne out of the country's most cinematically ignored regions is spot-on in terms of dialogue and performance, but the viewer is left with simple musings and exhibitions rather than meditations. It's a minor complaint - Sheridan is great, but has room to be brilliant.
And this is not at all to say that this is a mediocre script. What Sheridan may arguably lack in a Coen-level grasp of screenwriting language he makes up for with some very strong character writing and a grasp on how to build a tense, concise, and entertaining story. While still dark in its own right, this film is a great deal funnier and looser than Sicario, and with a great director like Denis Villeneuve may have even surpassed it. Mackenzie, though, does a very good job at striking a balance between moving the story along and letting it sit a while to resonate with viewers. While this movie starts with a bank robbery scene, it's not mindless gunplay and car chases from beginning to end. The film allows us to get to know our characters and build the tension so that its explosively violent conclusion is all the more dramatic.
That is really this film's high point - the characters and performances. Ben Foster aims to steal the show as a belligerent, borderline psychopathic man of action, and he is a great deal of fun to watch, but Chris Pine upstages him particularly in the second half. Pine's performance is one of surprising reservation and subtlety, and by the end he is one of the most gripping actors to watch onscreen. Jeff Bridges gives his best performance in several years, as well as delivering the vast majority of the comic relief. His relationship with his accomplice, played wonderfully by Gil Birmingham, was my favorite character dynamic in the film. It feels like a real friendship, albeit a troubled one that makes for some great drama in the last third of the film.
Ultimately, the dynamics between the two criminals, specifically Pine, and Bridges's sheriff character is what drives the thematic crux of the movie. Two men acting against a system they believe - with some good reason - has wronged them, and a sheriff who tells us before we justify too many of their actions, to remember that they're not saints or above the law. Both characters' worldviews are simplistic and biased, and it's what makes their characters interesting. And the characters' interactions with the various townsfolk who agree with our protagonists' lawlessness to varying degrees is, as I said before, while maybe lacking in significant subtext, note-perfect in execution. And when I think about it, though this is a rather timeless story structured like any good crime thriller, this movie is very much written for the now. In the political climate it was made for, those simple musings and on-their-face presentations of middle America may be all there needs to be to strike up conversation.
Overall, Hell or High Water is a smart, incredibly well-acted, and very entertaining crime thriller that, like Sicario, was just short of being really great. If you enjoy your violent crime dramas with some slow-burning tension and lots of character development as well as ample gunfights and manly talk, then it's a good time at the movies. And Jeff Bridges makes the second half very memorable - the climax alone is worth the price of admission.
Grade: A-
Between this, Sicario, and his work on the show Sons of Anarchy, Taylor Sheridan has a real interest and knack for writing modern-day crime. His greatest talent as well as his flaw as a screenwriter is that he is a pitch perfect scribe when it comes to observing and relaying said observations about modern America, but not so much at brilliantly expanding on them or offering any groundbreaking wisdom on them thematically. This film was described to me as a "dumbed down No Country for Old Men", which is fairly apt, if a little harsh. The movie isn't quite "dumb", just straightforward. Sheridan's presentations of post-financial crisis middle America, the casual racism of the South, and the general attitude of distrust and violence borne out of the country's most cinematically ignored regions is spot-on in terms of dialogue and performance, but the viewer is left with simple musings and exhibitions rather than meditations. It's a minor complaint - Sheridan is great, but has room to be brilliant.
And this is not at all to say that this is a mediocre script. What Sheridan may arguably lack in a Coen-level grasp of screenwriting language he makes up for with some very strong character writing and a grasp on how to build a tense, concise, and entertaining story. While still dark in its own right, this film is a great deal funnier and looser than Sicario, and with a great director like Denis Villeneuve may have even surpassed it. Mackenzie, though, does a very good job at striking a balance between moving the story along and letting it sit a while to resonate with viewers. While this movie starts with a bank robbery scene, it's not mindless gunplay and car chases from beginning to end. The film allows us to get to know our characters and build the tension so that its explosively violent conclusion is all the more dramatic.That is really this film's high point - the characters and performances. Ben Foster aims to steal the show as a belligerent, borderline psychopathic man of action, and he is a great deal of fun to watch, but Chris Pine upstages him particularly in the second half. Pine's performance is one of surprising reservation and subtlety, and by the end he is one of the most gripping actors to watch onscreen. Jeff Bridges gives his best performance in several years, as well as delivering the vast majority of the comic relief. His relationship with his accomplice, played wonderfully by Gil Birmingham, was my favorite character dynamic in the film. It feels like a real friendship, albeit a troubled one that makes for some great drama in the last third of the film.
Ultimately, the dynamics between the two criminals, specifically Pine, and Bridges's sheriff character is what drives the thematic crux of the movie. Two men acting against a system they believe - with some good reason - has wronged them, and a sheriff who tells us before we justify too many of their actions, to remember that they're not saints or above the law. Both characters' worldviews are simplistic and biased, and it's what makes their characters interesting. And the characters' interactions with the various townsfolk who agree with our protagonists' lawlessness to varying degrees is, as I said before, while maybe lacking in significant subtext, note-perfect in execution. And when I think about it, though this is a rather timeless story structured like any good crime thriller, this movie is very much written for the now. In the political climate it was made for, those simple musings and on-their-face presentations of middle America may be all there needs to be to strike up conversation.
Overall, Hell or High Water is a smart, incredibly well-acted, and very entertaining crime thriller that, like Sicario, was just short of being really great. If you enjoy your violent crime dramas with some slow-burning tension and lots of character development as well as ample gunfights and manly talk, then it's a good time at the movies. And Jeff Bridges makes the second half very memorable - the climax alone is worth the price of admission.
Grade: A-
August 22, 2016
"Kubo and the Two Strings" Review
Kubo and the Two Strings is a stop-motion animated fantasy adventure film directed by Travis Knight, written by Marc Haimes and Chris Butler, and featuring the voices of Art Parkinson, Charlize Theron, Matthew McConaughey, Rooney Mara, and Ralph Fiennes. It is produced by the animation studio Laika, known for such other stop-motion films as The Boxtrolls, ParaNorman, and Coraline. Set in ancient Japan, the film follows a young boy named Kubo, a renowned storyteller in his village who, through a set of unfortunate circumstances, is sent on a quest along with a monkey and a giant beetle man to find the three pieces of armor that once belonged to his late father, a noble and respected samurai, in order to fight off the spirits of his aunts and grandfather, who have a sinister plot against him regarding his family's past.
Laika has produced mostly quality work over the years, with Coraline probably still remaining my favorite of their films, although Kubo is a very close second. A behind-the-scenes featurette sent to me a while ago claimed that Kubo was Laika's most ambitious project yet, at least from a technical perspective, and the effort definitely shows. This is just about as beautiful as stop-motion animation gets. While it may not always reach the heights of visual cleverness and kid-friendly horror that Coraline did, Kubo is still a remarkably visually inspired film. From the camerawork to the character design to the absolutely gorgeous landscapes of the film's mythical Japan, Kubo does an excellent job of truly transporting you into its world. It's not often that I become legitimately transfixed in the universe a world creates, but Laika's world and characters feel like they live and breathe in front of you.
And the animation itself as well is craft of the highest caliber. Laika has definitely become experts at the art of stop-motion filmmaking. The animation here is remarkably fluid, and especially during sequences where they up the ante on the magic and mysticism, the film does wonders at being one of the rare films where you actually have to call into question how they managed to pull off these effects. From a towering skeleton that in reality was a full 16-foot rigged animatronic to the numerous magical origami creatures and objects Kubo creates as his magical abilities grow stronger, there are numerous effects and images in this film that are truly mesmerizing. I've always adored stop-motion animation for its hand-crafted feel that creates an unmatched sense of closeness and intimacy, and Laika turns that aspect of the art form up to 11 not just to great visual ends, but narrative ones as well.
Kubo and the Two Strings is a mature, thoughtful, and soulful film about family, mortality, memory, and stories. The screenplay is as meticulously and lovingly crafted as the world it takes place in, and our three main characters are interesting, sweet, and fun to watch. Theron and McConaughey provide great voice work to make two supporting characters that have genuine chemistry. While I will complain that the film's central villain has a rather weak motivation, the face-off between he and Kubo all feels very satisfying thanks to the rest of the story being so well-told. This film does not pander to its audience, and in fact, may actually be too scary and mature for younger kids. Kubo has many lengthy sequences of quiet, meditative dialogue that builds its characters, as well as the mythology of its world. Luckily, it has some colorful characters, humor, and exciting action sequences to keep slightly older kids hooked.
I really enjoyed the themes and message of this movie. You hear all the time about kids' films having "heart", but this is a film with genuine heart and soul. It's a film that argues for the importance of stories and the unbreakable connections of family in an appreciably non-treacly and creative way. This story is a bit more melancholy than your average animated film (which seems to be one of Laika's trademarks at this point), with death and loss being central components that are handled very bluntly and directly. But ultimately it's a film about how our memories and stories of the ones we love are what keep them alive - that the greatest "afterlife" is that which is carried on by others. It's an interesting spiritual message and it's done beautifully.
Overall, Kubo and the Two Strings was a very refreshing surprise after a summer that was on the whole pretty dull. It's well directed, smartly written, sweet, funny, and has some of the most gorgeous animation I've seen in quite a long time. It's pretty amazingly done in every aspect you could hope for, and I hope it finds a second life out of theaters, as it seems to be flopping at the box office unfortunately. Go support an original, beautiful-looking, enjoyable animated film by a studio that puts an immense amount of craft and care into their work. I recommend this one highly.
Grade: A
Laika has produced mostly quality work over the years, with Coraline probably still remaining my favorite of their films, although Kubo is a very close second. A behind-the-scenes featurette sent to me a while ago claimed that Kubo was Laika's most ambitious project yet, at least from a technical perspective, and the effort definitely shows. This is just about as beautiful as stop-motion animation gets. While it may not always reach the heights of visual cleverness and kid-friendly horror that Coraline did, Kubo is still a remarkably visually inspired film. From the camerawork to the character design to the absolutely gorgeous landscapes of the film's mythical Japan, Kubo does an excellent job of truly transporting you into its world. It's not often that I become legitimately transfixed in the universe a world creates, but Laika's world and characters feel like they live and breathe in front of you.
And the animation itself as well is craft of the highest caliber. Laika has definitely become experts at the art of stop-motion filmmaking. The animation here is remarkably fluid, and especially during sequences where they up the ante on the magic and mysticism, the film does wonders at being one of the rare films where you actually have to call into question how they managed to pull off these effects. From a towering skeleton that in reality was a full 16-foot rigged animatronic to the numerous magical origami creatures and objects Kubo creates as his magical abilities grow stronger, there are numerous effects and images in this film that are truly mesmerizing. I've always adored stop-motion animation for its hand-crafted feel that creates an unmatched sense of closeness and intimacy, and Laika turns that aspect of the art form up to 11 not just to great visual ends, but narrative ones as well.
Kubo and the Two Strings is a mature, thoughtful, and soulful film about family, mortality, memory, and stories. The screenplay is as meticulously and lovingly crafted as the world it takes place in, and our three main characters are interesting, sweet, and fun to watch. Theron and McConaughey provide great voice work to make two supporting characters that have genuine chemistry. While I will complain that the film's central villain has a rather weak motivation, the face-off between he and Kubo all feels very satisfying thanks to the rest of the story being so well-told. This film does not pander to its audience, and in fact, may actually be too scary and mature for younger kids. Kubo has many lengthy sequences of quiet, meditative dialogue that builds its characters, as well as the mythology of its world. Luckily, it has some colorful characters, humor, and exciting action sequences to keep slightly older kids hooked.
![]() |
| I had a tough time choosing just one or two screencaps from this film, since there are so many shots that are just incredible. |
I really enjoyed the themes and message of this movie. You hear all the time about kids' films having "heart", but this is a film with genuine heart and soul. It's a film that argues for the importance of stories and the unbreakable connections of family in an appreciably non-treacly and creative way. This story is a bit more melancholy than your average animated film (which seems to be one of Laika's trademarks at this point), with death and loss being central components that are handled very bluntly and directly. But ultimately it's a film about how our memories and stories of the ones we love are what keep them alive - that the greatest "afterlife" is that which is carried on by others. It's an interesting spiritual message and it's done beautifully.
Overall, Kubo and the Two Strings was a very refreshing surprise after a summer that was on the whole pretty dull. It's well directed, smartly written, sweet, funny, and has some of the most gorgeous animation I've seen in quite a long time. It's pretty amazingly done in every aspect you could hope for, and I hope it finds a second life out of theaters, as it seems to be flopping at the box office unfortunately. Go support an original, beautiful-looking, enjoyable animated film by a studio that puts an immense amount of craft and care into their work. I recommend this one highly.
Grade: A
August 21, 2016
"Sausage Party" Review
Sausage Party is a computer animated comedy film directed by Conrad Vernon and Greg Tiernan, written by Conrad Vernon, Megan Ellison, Seth Rogen, and Evan Goldberg, and featuring the voices of Rogen, Kristen Wiig, Jonah Hill, Bill Hader, Michael Cera, David Krumholtz, Nick Kroll, Edward Norton, Salma Hayek, James Franco, Danny McBride, Craig Robinson, Paul Rudd, Anders Holm and Lauren Miller. The film, in the tradition of Disney/Pixar's bringing to life of the mundane objects we know and love, follows the various products in a supermarket who await to be taken by the "gods" (humans) to the Great Beyond, where they believe they are showered with praise and happiness for eternity. When one skeptical sausage (Rogen) finds out what really happens to food once they get home, however, he sets out to convince his friends and the entire market that they've been misled and to fight back against the humans. In typical Seth Rogen movie fashion, this journey is accompanied by a plethora of expletives, shock humor, violence, ridiculous over-the-top jokes, marijuana, and - you must've heard by now - a three-minute animated food orgy. And some religious satire, bath salts, commentary on Middle Eastern conflicts, and even some displays of sexual pride. This movie is nuts.
Be warned - if you hate Seth Rogen and his brand of humor, and are especially repulsed by juvenile humor, excessive swearing, racial stereotypes, sex jokes, and just general button-pushing, then just stay away from Sausage Party. You will find little of worth. All the complaints I've heard about this film have been valid, as they've all come from people who simply thought this film was a reprehensibly stupid idea in the first place. I, for one, was really interested to see where Rogen and the gang would go with this, and I was pleasantly satisfied. But if you find yourself rolling your eyes at 90 minutes of food puns and dick jokes, there's not much I can say to convince you.
To me, though, there's something that sets aside Rogen and co. from the likes of Adam Sandler, who is also known for crass and vulgar humor. But in my view, simply having your comedic brow permanently lowered is not enough to discredit you as a comedy writer - what lacks from Sandler's films is a sense of caring or genuine interest in telling jokes and making films that do or say something. Though they've had both hits and misses, I applaud Rogen and Evan Goldberg for being genuinely intriguing comedic filmmakers that like to push the envelope with premises that are instantly attention-grabbing. Fictionalized versions of them and their friends waiting out the biblical apocalypse, two trash journalists sent to kill a sitting dictator, an animated film about talking food that swears - in my opinion, they're yet to top This is the End in terms of actually delivering on everything their premise entails, but these are ideas that are at least fun and interesting.
Most importantly, the jokes about dicks, race, and violence are not toward nothing. Rogen and his ilk typically engage in vulgarity for vulgarity's sake, and often times that's just about enough, because most of them have the comedic chops to pull it off. But here, there's something to be said for the film's use of over-the-top shock humor. The film primarily satirizes animated Disney films as well as blind faith in religion (yes, really), and its most over-the-top aspects serve both of these comedic aims. It is true that this film contains quite a few more racial stereotypes than past Rogen films (most of his work prefers to take potshots at his fellow Jews), but it's not like Adam Sandler where the humor is meant to derive just from the observation that these people are of a different ethnicity. It's there to make a point. Ultimately, taking from the Trey Parker and Matt Stone book, the film argues for the equal treatment of races, and uses these bizarre stereotypes as just one of its many tools of absurd-ifying every aspect of the satirical world it creates. In other words, the ridiculousness is meant to reflect the ridiculousness of our own world.
And really, this film's satire is the best thing going for it. Having an actual narrative goal to your over-the-top humor is a good cushion, and this film does it well, and it's funny as hell most of the time. For a film with an intriguing but admittedly flimsy and juvenile premise, Rogen and his team wring an impressive amount of genuine laughs. And it's not all relegated to penises and weed - there's some truly legendary food puns and wordplay, clever visual gags, self-referential meta-humor, and some great jabs at popular culture and the human condition in this film that starts off as a quick reversal of expectations for a computer animated film and soon becomes a surprisingly thoughtful meditation on theology, belief, and groupthink, as well as an open celebration of hedonism and gleeful nihilism that backs up an unbelievable amount of profanity and balls-to-the-wall insanity, especially in the third act.
Ultimately, the mass food orgy finale is not quite as much of a cop-out as the Backstreet Boys in heaven (Rogen has a tough time ending his comedies - it's all quite clever, but then he usually just goes for pleasantly silly at the end rather than wrapping his ideas together cleverly), and this is not gleefully offensive and shocking humor of the same satirical genius as South Park, but I'm impressed both with Rogen and his team's desire to incorporate some actual narrative ambition into such a juvenile premise, as well as his unabashed fearlessness as to what to put on a movie screen - though I guess after receiving death threats from North Korea, not much scares you as a filmmaker anymore. As someone who's seen a lot of non-mainstream adult animation filled with cursing and sex toward dramatic purpose rather than for laughs, as well as plenty of anime that can get pretty crazily violent, the novelty of animated things swearing and killing things and fucking each other wore off quickly, and there was a point where I felt like the filmmakers were relishing in their swearing cartoons maybe a little too much. But I know that for the average audience member in this neo-Puritan moviegoing society, this will be the first such foray into animated debauchery, and quite a shocking one at that, so I applaud Rogen and company for their courage on that front.
Overall, as I said before, if juvenile humor and button-pushing toward any purpose don't jibe with you, Sausage Party will not be your bag. It's offensive, profane, disgusting, and stupid - but also pretty clever and often very funny, at least in my opinion, and I have to give Seth Rogen and his crew some bonus points for sheer audacity and their commitment to cinematic anarchy. While this is not satirical shock-humor-with-a-purpose of the highest caliber, it's got some surprising tricks up its sleeve, and should be rewarded for possibly ushering in a new age of mainstream animated American entertainment for adults. If it sounds like something you're open to, check it out. I had a lot of fun.
Grade: B+
Be warned - if you hate Seth Rogen and his brand of humor, and are especially repulsed by juvenile humor, excessive swearing, racial stereotypes, sex jokes, and just general button-pushing, then just stay away from Sausage Party. You will find little of worth. All the complaints I've heard about this film have been valid, as they've all come from people who simply thought this film was a reprehensibly stupid idea in the first place. I, for one, was really interested to see where Rogen and the gang would go with this, and I was pleasantly satisfied. But if you find yourself rolling your eyes at 90 minutes of food puns and dick jokes, there's not much I can say to convince you.
To me, though, there's something that sets aside Rogen and co. from the likes of Adam Sandler, who is also known for crass and vulgar humor. But in my view, simply having your comedic brow permanently lowered is not enough to discredit you as a comedy writer - what lacks from Sandler's films is a sense of caring or genuine interest in telling jokes and making films that do or say something. Though they've had both hits and misses, I applaud Rogen and Evan Goldberg for being genuinely intriguing comedic filmmakers that like to push the envelope with premises that are instantly attention-grabbing. Fictionalized versions of them and their friends waiting out the biblical apocalypse, two trash journalists sent to kill a sitting dictator, an animated film about talking food that swears - in my opinion, they're yet to top This is the End in terms of actually delivering on everything their premise entails, but these are ideas that are at least fun and interesting.
Most importantly, the jokes about dicks, race, and violence are not toward nothing. Rogen and his ilk typically engage in vulgarity for vulgarity's sake, and often times that's just about enough, because most of them have the comedic chops to pull it off. But here, there's something to be said for the film's use of over-the-top shock humor. The film primarily satirizes animated Disney films as well as blind faith in religion (yes, really), and its most over-the-top aspects serve both of these comedic aims. It is true that this film contains quite a few more racial stereotypes than past Rogen films (most of his work prefers to take potshots at his fellow Jews), but it's not like Adam Sandler where the humor is meant to derive just from the observation that these people are of a different ethnicity. It's there to make a point. Ultimately, taking from the Trey Parker and Matt Stone book, the film argues for the equal treatment of races, and uses these bizarre stereotypes as just one of its many tools of absurd-ifying every aspect of the satirical world it creates. In other words, the ridiculousness is meant to reflect the ridiculousness of our own world.
And really, this film's satire is the best thing going for it. Having an actual narrative goal to your over-the-top humor is a good cushion, and this film does it well, and it's funny as hell most of the time. For a film with an intriguing but admittedly flimsy and juvenile premise, Rogen and his team wring an impressive amount of genuine laughs. And it's not all relegated to penises and weed - there's some truly legendary food puns and wordplay, clever visual gags, self-referential meta-humor, and some great jabs at popular culture and the human condition in this film that starts off as a quick reversal of expectations for a computer animated film and soon becomes a surprisingly thoughtful meditation on theology, belief, and groupthink, as well as an open celebration of hedonism and gleeful nihilism that backs up an unbelievable amount of profanity and balls-to-the-wall insanity, especially in the third act.
Ultimately, the mass food orgy finale is not quite as much of a cop-out as the Backstreet Boys in heaven (Rogen has a tough time ending his comedies - it's all quite clever, but then he usually just goes for pleasantly silly at the end rather than wrapping his ideas together cleverly), and this is not gleefully offensive and shocking humor of the same satirical genius as South Park, but I'm impressed both with Rogen and his team's desire to incorporate some actual narrative ambition into such a juvenile premise, as well as his unabashed fearlessness as to what to put on a movie screen - though I guess after receiving death threats from North Korea, not much scares you as a filmmaker anymore. As someone who's seen a lot of non-mainstream adult animation filled with cursing and sex toward dramatic purpose rather than for laughs, as well as plenty of anime that can get pretty crazily violent, the novelty of animated things swearing and killing things and fucking each other wore off quickly, and there was a point where I felt like the filmmakers were relishing in their swearing cartoons maybe a little too much. But I know that for the average audience member in this neo-Puritan moviegoing society, this will be the first such foray into animated debauchery, and quite a shocking one at that, so I applaud Rogen and company for their courage on that front.
Overall, as I said before, if juvenile humor and button-pushing toward any purpose don't jibe with you, Sausage Party will not be your bag. It's offensive, profane, disgusting, and stupid - but also pretty clever and often very funny, at least in my opinion, and I have to give Seth Rogen and his crew some bonus points for sheer audacity and their commitment to cinematic anarchy. While this is not satirical shock-humor-with-a-purpose of the highest caliber, it's got some surprising tricks up its sleeve, and should be rewarded for possibly ushering in a new age of mainstream animated American entertainment for adults. If it sounds like something you're open to, check it out. I had a lot of fun.
Grade: B+
August 11, 2016
"Suicide Squad" Review
Suicide Squad is a superhero film directed and written by David Ayer and the third film in the DC Extended Universe, starring Will Smith, Margot Robbie, Jared Leto, Joel Kinnaman, Jai Courtney, Jay Hernandez, Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje, Ike Barinholtz, Viola Davis, and Cara Delevingne. It follows the Suicide Squad, a group of supervillains banded together by Amanda Waller (Davis) to be used as pawns by the federal government to stop a potential evil Superman-like figure. In the event that an indestructible superpowered alien comes to Earth with the intent of destroying a city again, the cunning and clever Waller recruits Harley Quinn with a baseball bat and some nerds with guns as part of her flawless plan. In an effort to recruit, she accidentally unleashes Enchantress (Delevingne), an evil sorceress witch lady bent on retrieving her stolen heart and taking over the world with giant CG clouds and magic who can summon demons by belly-dancing. Will Smith plays Deadshot, who leads Margot Robbie's Harley Quinn and a team of ragtag antiheroes to fight this faux-terrorist attack that is all Amanda Waller's fault in exchange for leaner prison sentences. The Joker makes a special cameo appearance.
So, you'd probably guess from my snarky intro that I thought Suicide Squad was kind of silly. But you're wrong - I thought it was a huge mess. I'm actually inclined to give it a lower rating than I've ended up giving it because I've already been wronged by DC in this way before - only five months ago, actually. I still consider Batman v Superman to be the worse film, but they both suffer from many of the same core issues, all of which lead back to ineptitude on the part of Warner Bros. If anything, though, Suicide Squad is more frustrating because unlike BvS, I saw glimmers of things that could've been interesting or fun. So in a way, it was actually more disappointing.
Suicide Squad's first trailer sold it as what David Ayer's apparent original vision for the film was - a dark, thought-provoking action thriller about a team of misfit antiheroes employed by a sadistic cold-blooded government agent to take down other forces of evil. Evil working for secret evil to combat obvious evil. It works well with the whole almost neo-noir levels of nihilism and ambiguity regarding morals and justice in the Gotham/DC universe. Partway through marketing, though, the film suddenly became a sort of color-drained Guardians of the Galaxy for the Hot Topic crowd with blaring pop rock tunes, flashy zany characters, and tons of reshoots and re-cuts to compensate for the change after numerous test audiences found the original film to be too dark and upsetting. Warner Bros/DC panicked and created this instead, and the result is something that can only barely be called a finished product.
Now, knowing the backstory of this movie's cobbled-together production process and the unsettling influence of social media on its release is only gravy in the discussion of why this movie is bad, but it adds some healthy perspective as to where these flaws can be drawn from. The biggest and most glaring problem, to me, with this film is the editing and direction, most likely because these jobs were originally handled by one person each and then sent off to be redone by about seven or eight people in post. The film has almost zero flow, with jarring tonal shifts not just from act to act but from scene to scene. There are jittery flashbacks, awkward insertions of humor, and no structure to how the story is told - we're introduced to most of our characters in the first 30 minutes via Viola Davis's show-and-tell monologue, then introduced to most of them again in subsequent individual scenes, and then other main characters are haphazardly tacked on throughout the setup for the second act that is actually the setup for the real story of the film. Oh, and we don't get an action scene until about halfway through the movie.
Taking again from the playbook of Guardians (often right down to the actual choice of songs), this film is full with popular classic rock and pop songs. And by "full", I mean it has literally a couple dozen of them, and almost all of them feel inappropriately shoved in. Yet another symptom of post-completion studio meddling, many of the scenes feel like they were shot entirely separate from the song accompanying them, and so they often feel jarring and tonally inconsistent, and often these epic song breaks only last for about 30 seconds to underscore establishing shots. The film cuts off "Bohemian Rhapsody" before the atmosphere it creates really gets to go anywhere before fading into generic blockbuster score.

Entire sequences feel tacked on, such as a very awkward 30-second brawl between Harley Quinn and some faceless zombies in an elevator that progresses absolutely nothing in the story. By the way, the action feels just as jumbled as well - while DC has expanded their color palette vaguely beyond grays, blacks, and browns, almost all the scenes are unimpressively shot or borderline incomprehensible at times, and when they are visible, they're still toothless and tensionless. Lots of guns and punching, but very little stakes (probably because the film is too manic and jarring to establish any sort of comprehensible rising action).
We can talk forever about whether this movie is a product of a true visionary director having his vision taken from him by the studios, and David Ayer is admittedly much more of an auteur than Zack Snyder (though that's not saying much). But some fundamental script and structural problems, much like BvS, make me think that this movie wouldn't have been a complete success had it not been messed with afterward. That said, I'd be more willing to forgive muddled characters and incoherent storytelling, which aren't too uncommon in big blockbusters, if the presentation of such flaws was actually enjoyable.
To close out, let's talk about those characters, by the way. The standout performances by far were Robbie as Harley Quinn, Will Smith as Deadshot, and Jai Courtney as Boomerang, of all people. Along with Hernandez's Diablo, these are the four most interesting and entertaining characters, the former three because of their performances and the latter one because of his actually well-handled backstory. Robbie saves the under-written Harley with her comedic charm (although by the end of the film she gets too far into quippy territory and some of the humor is really reaching), and Jai Courtney manages to play a human being with a personality for the first time in cinematic history. Deadshot and Diablo are given appropriate backstories, unlike the vast majority of the characters who do almost nothing and who we are expected to believe are best friends after three hours of minor violence and are expected to fall in love with and care about after 80 minutes of scattershot psychedelic flashbacks. Enchantress is a laughable villain, both in writing and performance. It would've made perfect "so bad it's good" cringe fodder if this film had more fully committed to its wackiness (it becomes suddenly dark and emotional in the second half, especially during a nice bar scene, and it's actually enjoyable, but at that point completely unearned).
The biggest disappointment by far is Jared Leto as the Joker, whom the marketing hyped up quite a bit. Apparently the majority of the footage for the Joker was left on the cutting room floor, primarily because audiences didn't like watching a bad guy abuse his girlfriend. I'm almost glad we didn't get to see much of the Joker though, because Leto's performance was a lot like Jesse Eisenberg's Lex Luthor, in that he tried to sell almost sexual writhing, growling, and eccentricity as mental instability and depth. It didn't work for Lex, and it doesn't work the Joker, and now we are entering a cinematic universe where the two biggest comic book supervillains of all-time are played by actors who read their lines like this guy from Foodfight.
Overall, Suicide Squad isn't nearly as dour and joyless as Batman v Superman, but is just as slapped together, incoherent, messy, sloppily written, and too much too early for the DC cinematic universe, which is now 0 for 3 for me. It has some decent performances and a few short moments that are cool, but these are too short and too few and far between to recommend sitting through the entire movie for them. Instead of constructing scenes that flow together in a coherent structure to tell a story, DC has focused on creating "moments" that are marketable and digestible at the expense of creating a story and characters that have actual weight or logic. It's not absolute unforgivable garbage or anything, but at least for me, it too often toed the line of boring and desperate, neither of which are favorable. If you're a DC fanatic and/or have loved the last two DCEU films, however, you will probably enjoy yourself seeing some likable characters come to life. I, on the other hand, can't say I'm too excited for whatever DC has in store.
Grade: C-
So, you'd probably guess from my snarky intro that I thought Suicide Squad was kind of silly. But you're wrong - I thought it was a huge mess. I'm actually inclined to give it a lower rating than I've ended up giving it because I've already been wronged by DC in this way before - only five months ago, actually. I still consider Batman v Superman to be the worse film, but they both suffer from many of the same core issues, all of which lead back to ineptitude on the part of Warner Bros. If anything, though, Suicide Squad is more frustrating because unlike BvS, I saw glimmers of things that could've been interesting or fun. So in a way, it was actually more disappointing.
Suicide Squad's first trailer sold it as what David Ayer's apparent original vision for the film was - a dark, thought-provoking action thriller about a team of misfit antiheroes employed by a sadistic cold-blooded government agent to take down other forces of evil. Evil working for secret evil to combat obvious evil. It works well with the whole almost neo-noir levels of nihilism and ambiguity regarding morals and justice in the Gotham/DC universe. Partway through marketing, though, the film suddenly became a sort of color-drained Guardians of the Galaxy for the Hot Topic crowd with blaring pop rock tunes, flashy zany characters, and tons of reshoots and re-cuts to compensate for the change after numerous test audiences found the original film to be too dark and upsetting. Warner Bros/DC panicked and created this instead, and the result is something that can only barely be called a finished product.
Now, knowing the backstory of this movie's cobbled-together production process and the unsettling influence of social media on its release is only gravy in the discussion of why this movie is bad, but it adds some healthy perspective as to where these flaws can be drawn from. The biggest and most glaring problem, to me, with this film is the editing and direction, most likely because these jobs were originally handled by one person each and then sent off to be redone by about seven or eight people in post. The film has almost zero flow, with jarring tonal shifts not just from act to act but from scene to scene. There are jittery flashbacks, awkward insertions of humor, and no structure to how the story is told - we're introduced to most of our characters in the first 30 minutes via Viola Davis's show-and-tell monologue, then introduced to most of them again in subsequent individual scenes, and then other main characters are haphazardly tacked on throughout the setup for the second act that is actually the setup for the real story of the film. Oh, and we don't get an action scene until about halfway through the movie.
Taking again from the playbook of Guardians (often right down to the actual choice of songs), this film is full with popular classic rock and pop songs. And by "full", I mean it has literally a couple dozen of them, and almost all of them feel inappropriately shoved in. Yet another symptom of post-completion studio meddling, many of the scenes feel like they were shot entirely separate from the song accompanying them, and so they often feel jarring and tonally inconsistent, and often these epic song breaks only last for about 30 seconds to underscore establishing shots. The film cuts off "Bohemian Rhapsody" before the atmosphere it creates really gets to go anywhere before fading into generic blockbuster score.

Entire sequences feel tacked on, such as a very awkward 30-second brawl between Harley Quinn and some faceless zombies in an elevator that progresses absolutely nothing in the story. By the way, the action feels just as jumbled as well - while DC has expanded their color palette vaguely beyond grays, blacks, and browns, almost all the scenes are unimpressively shot or borderline incomprehensible at times, and when they are visible, they're still toothless and tensionless. Lots of guns and punching, but very little stakes (probably because the film is too manic and jarring to establish any sort of comprehensible rising action).
We can talk forever about whether this movie is a product of a true visionary director having his vision taken from him by the studios, and David Ayer is admittedly much more of an auteur than Zack Snyder (though that's not saying much). But some fundamental script and structural problems, much like BvS, make me think that this movie wouldn't have been a complete success had it not been messed with afterward. That said, I'd be more willing to forgive muddled characters and incoherent storytelling, which aren't too uncommon in big blockbusters, if the presentation of such flaws was actually enjoyable.
To close out, let's talk about those characters, by the way. The standout performances by far were Robbie as Harley Quinn, Will Smith as Deadshot, and Jai Courtney as Boomerang, of all people. Along with Hernandez's Diablo, these are the four most interesting and entertaining characters, the former three because of their performances and the latter one because of his actually well-handled backstory. Robbie saves the under-written Harley with her comedic charm (although by the end of the film she gets too far into quippy territory and some of the humor is really reaching), and Jai Courtney manages to play a human being with a personality for the first time in cinematic history. Deadshot and Diablo are given appropriate backstories, unlike the vast majority of the characters who do almost nothing and who we are expected to believe are best friends after three hours of minor violence and are expected to fall in love with and care about after 80 minutes of scattershot psychedelic flashbacks. Enchantress is a laughable villain, both in writing and performance. It would've made perfect "so bad it's good" cringe fodder if this film had more fully committed to its wackiness (it becomes suddenly dark and emotional in the second half, especially during a nice bar scene, and it's actually enjoyable, but at that point completely unearned).
![]() |
| Fun fact: This shot is literally not even in the actual film. |
The biggest disappointment by far is Jared Leto as the Joker, whom the marketing hyped up quite a bit. Apparently the majority of the footage for the Joker was left on the cutting room floor, primarily because audiences didn't like watching a bad guy abuse his girlfriend. I'm almost glad we didn't get to see much of the Joker though, because Leto's performance was a lot like Jesse Eisenberg's Lex Luthor, in that he tried to sell almost sexual writhing, growling, and eccentricity as mental instability and depth. It didn't work for Lex, and it doesn't work the Joker, and now we are entering a cinematic universe where the two biggest comic book supervillains of all-time are played by actors who read their lines like this guy from Foodfight.
Overall, Suicide Squad isn't nearly as dour and joyless as Batman v Superman, but is just as slapped together, incoherent, messy, sloppily written, and too much too early for the DC cinematic universe, which is now 0 for 3 for me. It has some decent performances and a few short moments that are cool, but these are too short and too few and far between to recommend sitting through the entire movie for them. Instead of constructing scenes that flow together in a coherent structure to tell a story, DC has focused on creating "moments" that are marketable and digestible at the expense of creating a story and characters that have actual weight or logic. It's not absolute unforgivable garbage or anything, but at least for me, it too often toed the line of boring and desperate, neither of which are favorable. If you're a DC fanatic and/or have loved the last two DCEU films, however, you will probably enjoy yourself seeing some likable characters come to life. I, on the other hand, can't say I'm too excited for whatever DC has in store.
Grade: C-
July 27, 2016
"Horace and Pete" Season 1 Review
Horace and Pete is a webseries created, written, and directed by Louis C.K., who also stars in an ensemble cast featuring Steve Buscemi, Alan Alda, Jessica Lange, Edie Falco, Aidy Bryant, Kurt Mentzger, Steven Wright, Tom Noonan, Michael Cyril Creighton, and Liza Treyger. The series follows Horace (C.K.) and his brother Pete (Buscemi), two middle-aged guys who run an old run-down Irish bar in Brooklyn called Horace and Pete's, along with the help of the bar's last co-owner, their Uncle Pete (Alda). The bar, celebrating its one hundredth year, is incredibly traditional at the demand of Uncle Pete - it serves no mixed drinks (only Budweiser and straight liquor), the prices are variable, and the owners have a history of watering down the alcohol to make up for dwindling profits. The bar's future is put at stake when Horace and Pete's sister Sylvia (Falco) arrives announcing that she wants to sell the bar for $6 million and tear it down so that she can pay for her cancer treatment, Pete can pay for the medication for his severe mental illness, and so Horace can finally move on to a better life, one that hopefully involves a greater presence with his college-age daughter (Bryant). This sets into motion a series of events revealing the devastating and horrific past of this cast of characters, and the incredible history the bar holds.
Horace and Pete is not a comedy. Louie himself has described it as a tragedy. And while this show does have moments of Louie's signature blend of vicarious embarrassment, incredibly dark humor, and surrealism with genuine pathos, Horace and Pete tends to lean more toward the latter. And the result is absolutely devastating - this show is heavy, and addresses a wide array of issues like mental illness, suicide, alcoholism, infidelity, mortality, racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, child abuse. It's intense. But man, does Louie handle it well.
Louie's strength has always been his writing, though I've seen his talents in direction only get better over time, and that is fully demonstrated with this show. Admittedly, of all the main actors in the show, Louie himself is probably the weakest player of the bunch, but in his defense, he surrounds himself with a circle of immense talent, with Buscemi and Alda in particular giving some absolutely stunning performances. Outside of that, Louie's writing here is particularly top-notch, which is commendable considering this show is even more engagingly ambitious, poetic, and narratively complex than almost any episode of Louie, although I admittedly still like that show more.
The show deals with, primarily, the theme of old vs. new, and more specifically, tradition vs. progress. This is evident most obviously in the relationship between Uncle Pete, who is sort of an even more stripped-down and outwardly hateful Archie Bunker type, and Horace and Pete Jr., two deadbeat schlubs beginning to wonder if the bar is a dead-end. In one of the first episodes, Pete tells Horace that he's been trying to do certain rituals in the mornings and nights to motivate him to keep going during the day, whereas Horace admits he's been trying to sleep through most of his days so the second half of his life can finish quickly. This is also shown through numerous clashes of old and new within the many subplots of the story, such as Pete dating a 26-year-old woman and Horace having to be updated on the particulars of the transgender experience even though he professes a belief in equal rights for everyone.

But this theme is also present in more subtle aspects of the show's production. The show was inspired by both the work of film director Mike Leigh and specifically the play Abigail's Party, which like this series focuses on a family and generations past in the place where they all grew up. The show is shot in a multi-camera sitcom style but features no laugh track or audience, as well as very little sound mixing or music. The show is inspired by the "TV theater" style of the 1950s, and yet is only available on Louie's website, as he wanted from the beginning to completely eschew the traditional television model. One could say such a decision wasn't a deliberate effort on Louie's part as some sort of creative choice relevant to the actual show, but in interviews and explanations of the show he seemed to have been very adamant about shooting and distributing the show in this very particular way.
The show really becomes intriguing, however, during the conversations between many of the regulars at the bar, usually about politics. Each episode of the show was shot the week that it would be aired, which allowed Louie to write in current events for the bar patrons to discuss. So, if you're sick of hearing about Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton and the 2016 election, sorry, this show will not provide any escape. But this is where, in my opinion, the show's true brilliance stands out - Louie juxtaposes the cyclical suffering of a few generations of a family on the brink of making a decision to try something new and scary or try to stick with tradition with the seemingly cyclical suffering of America on the brink of making a similar decision. And all possible angles are considered.
In a particularly brilliant scene, one bar patron asks a liberal patron and a conservative patron who are arguing to explain what they believe their respective ideologies mean to them, rather than just whining about what they preconceive the other's to be like. Once they take the time to listen, they understand each other's position a bit better. This works in tandem with the storyline of what to do with the bar. The show presents the ugliness as well as the value in keeping up with tradition, and also presents the value as well as the potential chaos in letting things go and trying something new for the sake of it. But the important part is to listen to both. One episode ends with a quote from the late Garry Shandling about the value of silence - that if everyone just shut up for a minute, maybe we could figure something out. We need to talk, we need to debate to figure things out, but to do that well, we all need to be able to listen, for real. (Indeed, even in practice, the show embraces silence by having nearly no diegetic sound, a choice that is distracting at first but ultimately allows the words and moods of the characters to really be felt.)
It's tempting, though, the show admits, as things complicate both in the political world and in the world of our characters' seemingly endless grief, to just give up. One bar patron, when speaking of his opinion on the election, recommends voting for Trump just to burn the country down because "we deserve it". Both Petes, likewise, have moments throughout the show where they consider giving up, and Horace's fatal flaw is that he's often too much of a loser to even decide which he wants to do. But the show encourages people to not give up, because, as Pete says as one point when asked why everyone on Earth doesn't just kill themselves amidst all the turmoil, "Maybe it gets better."
And Louie proposes all of this, mainly, through the experiences and history of a family. Louie has made the analogy of the country or the world being like a family before in his stand-up, referring to America as the world's "shitty girlfriend", and comparing Israel and Palestine to the relationship his daughters have with each other. This is just an extension of that. The good times, as well as the suffering, in the Wittel family is cyclical until one member or life itself forces change in some direction, and Louie makes that connection to the world as well. That we're gonna always have horrible stuff come up, and we're always gonna disagree, but if we give up, never decide, or just plant our feet firmly where we want and never listen to anyone else, the hurt will only get worse. He shows that to be true for both politics and for his cast of characters, who all make some variation of those decisions (which makes Louie's description of the show as a tragedy ring true, as pretty much everyone suffers by their own flaws).
Outside of listening, though, I believe the show argues most importantly for being a good person through all of this. Tom Noonan's character gives an awkward but ultimately tender monologue toward the series' closing that punching an area of pain doesn't make it go away; you have to treat it, and that people are the same way - when people, the country, or life hurt you, you can't hurt them back and expect the pain to diminish. There has to be love and care for others at the root of your decisions. Listen to people, be nice to them, and don't just give up when things are hard, because things are always going to be hard, but not doing these things just makes those times harder. Give Louis C.K. some credit for being able to make an ultimately positive and thoughtful remark about tradition vs. progress while still being gut-wrenching, darkly comic, and having one of the most bizarre twist endings to any series ever.
I have no idea where this show could go. Louie has expressed interest in a second season, and I have confidence that he has an idea for it that is completely outside of my imagination. This show will not at all be for everyone, but it's an impressively ambitious step forward and some kind of revelation for Louie as an art-maker. As a long-time fan, it's interesting to think that he was known for dick and fart jokes just nine years ago, and now has made more than one TV show that have really hit close to home - while, of course, still delivering the dick and fart jokes in spades. And here he has further upped the ante by engaging us with this story that begs us to treat each other nicely, listen to others, and not give into emotion in a global situation where he seems to feel we desperately need to hear it most.
Please actually buy Horace and Pete, don't pirate it, and give it a try. It's incredibly unorthodox, painful, surreal, and beguilingly intelligent and endearing, as well as thoroughly engrossing. If the last two or three seasons of Louie haven't been your bag and you prefer the sillier side of him, this will not deliver. But if you're looking for a TV show that is truly wildly unlike any other you'll ever see, as well as some very smart (and, by the way, not at all partisan) sociopolitical commentary and pathos, then I can't recommend Horace and Pete enough. I could write about it for hours. To me, Louie's artistic career is really just starting, and I'm immensely excited to see his growth as a writer and artist in the future.
I don't give grades to TV shows due to how infrequently I review them, but this would undoubtedly be an A or an A+.
Horace and Pete is not a comedy. Louie himself has described it as a tragedy. And while this show does have moments of Louie's signature blend of vicarious embarrassment, incredibly dark humor, and surrealism with genuine pathos, Horace and Pete tends to lean more toward the latter. And the result is absolutely devastating - this show is heavy, and addresses a wide array of issues like mental illness, suicide, alcoholism, infidelity, mortality, racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, child abuse. It's intense. But man, does Louie handle it well.
Louie's strength has always been his writing, though I've seen his talents in direction only get better over time, and that is fully demonstrated with this show. Admittedly, of all the main actors in the show, Louie himself is probably the weakest player of the bunch, but in his defense, he surrounds himself with a circle of immense talent, with Buscemi and Alda in particular giving some absolutely stunning performances. Outside of that, Louie's writing here is particularly top-notch, which is commendable considering this show is even more engagingly ambitious, poetic, and narratively complex than almost any episode of Louie, although I admittedly still like that show more.
The show deals with, primarily, the theme of old vs. new, and more specifically, tradition vs. progress. This is evident most obviously in the relationship between Uncle Pete, who is sort of an even more stripped-down and outwardly hateful Archie Bunker type, and Horace and Pete Jr., two deadbeat schlubs beginning to wonder if the bar is a dead-end. In one of the first episodes, Pete tells Horace that he's been trying to do certain rituals in the mornings and nights to motivate him to keep going during the day, whereas Horace admits he's been trying to sleep through most of his days so the second half of his life can finish quickly. This is also shown through numerous clashes of old and new within the many subplots of the story, such as Pete dating a 26-year-old woman and Horace having to be updated on the particulars of the transgender experience even though he professes a belief in equal rights for everyone.

But this theme is also present in more subtle aspects of the show's production. The show was inspired by both the work of film director Mike Leigh and specifically the play Abigail's Party, which like this series focuses on a family and generations past in the place where they all grew up. The show is shot in a multi-camera sitcom style but features no laugh track or audience, as well as very little sound mixing or music. The show is inspired by the "TV theater" style of the 1950s, and yet is only available on Louie's website, as he wanted from the beginning to completely eschew the traditional television model. One could say such a decision wasn't a deliberate effort on Louie's part as some sort of creative choice relevant to the actual show, but in interviews and explanations of the show he seemed to have been very adamant about shooting and distributing the show in this very particular way.
The show really becomes intriguing, however, during the conversations between many of the regulars at the bar, usually about politics. Each episode of the show was shot the week that it would be aired, which allowed Louie to write in current events for the bar patrons to discuss. So, if you're sick of hearing about Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton and the 2016 election, sorry, this show will not provide any escape. But this is where, in my opinion, the show's true brilliance stands out - Louie juxtaposes the cyclical suffering of a few generations of a family on the brink of making a decision to try something new and scary or try to stick with tradition with the seemingly cyclical suffering of America on the brink of making a similar decision. And all possible angles are considered.
In a particularly brilliant scene, one bar patron asks a liberal patron and a conservative patron who are arguing to explain what they believe their respective ideologies mean to them, rather than just whining about what they preconceive the other's to be like. Once they take the time to listen, they understand each other's position a bit better. This works in tandem with the storyline of what to do with the bar. The show presents the ugliness as well as the value in keeping up with tradition, and also presents the value as well as the potential chaos in letting things go and trying something new for the sake of it. But the important part is to listen to both. One episode ends with a quote from the late Garry Shandling about the value of silence - that if everyone just shut up for a minute, maybe we could figure something out. We need to talk, we need to debate to figure things out, but to do that well, we all need to be able to listen, for real. (Indeed, even in practice, the show embraces silence by having nearly no diegetic sound, a choice that is distracting at first but ultimately allows the words and moods of the characters to really be felt.)
It's tempting, though, the show admits, as things complicate both in the political world and in the world of our characters' seemingly endless grief, to just give up. One bar patron, when speaking of his opinion on the election, recommends voting for Trump just to burn the country down because "we deserve it". Both Petes, likewise, have moments throughout the show where they consider giving up, and Horace's fatal flaw is that he's often too much of a loser to even decide which he wants to do. But the show encourages people to not give up, because, as Pete says as one point when asked why everyone on Earth doesn't just kill themselves amidst all the turmoil, "Maybe it gets better."
And Louie proposes all of this, mainly, through the experiences and history of a family. Louie has made the analogy of the country or the world being like a family before in his stand-up, referring to America as the world's "shitty girlfriend", and comparing Israel and Palestine to the relationship his daughters have with each other. This is just an extension of that. The good times, as well as the suffering, in the Wittel family is cyclical until one member or life itself forces change in some direction, and Louie makes that connection to the world as well. That we're gonna always have horrible stuff come up, and we're always gonna disagree, but if we give up, never decide, or just plant our feet firmly where we want and never listen to anyone else, the hurt will only get worse. He shows that to be true for both politics and for his cast of characters, who all make some variation of those decisions (which makes Louie's description of the show as a tragedy ring true, as pretty much everyone suffers by their own flaws).
Outside of listening, though, I believe the show argues most importantly for being a good person through all of this. Tom Noonan's character gives an awkward but ultimately tender monologue toward the series' closing that punching an area of pain doesn't make it go away; you have to treat it, and that people are the same way - when people, the country, or life hurt you, you can't hurt them back and expect the pain to diminish. There has to be love and care for others at the root of your decisions. Listen to people, be nice to them, and don't just give up when things are hard, because things are always going to be hard, but not doing these things just makes those times harder. Give Louis C.K. some credit for being able to make an ultimately positive and thoughtful remark about tradition vs. progress while still being gut-wrenching, darkly comic, and having one of the most bizarre twist endings to any series ever.
I have no idea where this show could go. Louie has expressed interest in a second season, and I have confidence that he has an idea for it that is completely outside of my imagination. This show will not at all be for everyone, but it's an impressively ambitious step forward and some kind of revelation for Louie as an art-maker. As a long-time fan, it's interesting to think that he was known for dick and fart jokes just nine years ago, and now has made more than one TV show that have really hit close to home - while, of course, still delivering the dick and fart jokes in spades. And here he has further upped the ante by engaging us with this story that begs us to treat each other nicely, listen to others, and not give into emotion in a global situation where he seems to feel we desperately need to hear it most.
Please actually buy Horace and Pete, don't pirate it, and give it a try. It's incredibly unorthodox, painful, surreal, and beguilingly intelligent and endearing, as well as thoroughly engrossing. If the last two or three seasons of Louie haven't been your bag and you prefer the sillier side of him, this will not deliver. But if you're looking for a TV show that is truly wildly unlike any other you'll ever see, as well as some very smart (and, by the way, not at all partisan) sociopolitical commentary and pathos, then I can't recommend Horace and Pete enough. I could write about it for hours. To me, Louie's artistic career is really just starting, and I'm immensely excited to see his growth as a writer and artist in the future.
I don't give grades to TV shows due to how infrequently I review them, but this would undoubtedly be an A or an A+.
July 24, 2016
Thoughts on the New 2016 Comic Con Trailers
The 2016 San Diego Comic Con is here, and unfortunately I've never been able to go to one, but the convention still manages to deliver for those who can't make it, primarily due to the abundance of posters, concept art, movie news, revelations, and trailers that have come out. Today was a pretty gigantic day for Comic Con news, and while I haven't been following the event nearly closely enough to have an exhaustive list of updates to talk about, I did see quite a few trailers that I thought I'd give some thoughts on. I'll say right off the bat that I won't be reviewing the trailer for Blair Witch. Originally masquerading as Adam Wingard's The Woods, the film has now been revealed to actually be a secret sequel to 1999's The Blair Witch Project. It would've been nice for the movie to be completely kept secret until release, although I realize from a marketing standpoint why that would've made absolutely no sense (although, if I remember correctly, didn't the first movie take like $10,000 to make or something?). But wouldn't it be bananas for there to be a movie in this day and age that just appeared out of nowhere and people could watch without knowing much? It certainly would be a counter-point to most modern trailers' sensibility of outlining the entire plot. But, c'est la vie.
Was the shitty Pokemon movie news from Comic Con or did the news just come out the same week as Comic Con? Whatever, this week it came out that Legendary had acquired the rights to a live-action Pokemon movie shortly after Nintendo's announcement that they wanted to venture into filmmaking, and obviously coasting on the new-found success of Pokemon Go. Unfortunately, unlike my idea for a live-action Pokemon movie (sort of a Goonies-style thing with scrappy young kids who want to catch all the Pokemon to stop a bully or a mean adult or whatever kids' movie trope you want), they'll be making it a...Pikachu detective movie? Fuck it, it can't be as bad as the emoji movie, I guess.
One other snippet of news to come out of Comic Con so far that I enjoyed was the putting to bed of rumors that Brie Larson would be cast in the titular role of Captain Marvel in 2019, with Marvel Studios making the official announcement this week and Brie tweeting this absolutely perfect photograph. Marvel's string of fairly decent blockbusters and my undying love for Brie Larson should make Captain Marvel a fun time in... three years. Anyway, on to the trailers.
First up is the second trailer for Marvel's Doctor Strange, out this November. I know absolutely nothing about Doctor Strange the character, and the connection between being a surgeon and a sorcerer is kind of wonky to me but I'm sure there'll be ample reasoning given that this is an origin story movie. Between the kaleidoscope Marvel logo, the ripple punch in the skyscraper, the shards of air, and the window and pillar perspective tomfoolery, this movie looks set to have second-half-of-Inception-level mindfuck visual effects, which I'm all for - and it'll probably look palpably dope in 3D, which is great for my eyes as well as Kevin Feige's wallet. Chiwetel Ejiofor's wi-fi crack at the end shows that this will have Marvel's requisite bordering-on-fourth-wall-breaking snarky quips, which is welcome until it inevitably becomes stale after their 40th movie.
And while I love Mads Mikkelsen and he looks baller as the main villain, it looks like this movie will be devolving into another pretty typical Marvel "god-man destroys the entire planet" effects party of a climax. Which is fine, but like, we gotta switch it up soon. Oh well, we got Guardians 2 in 10 months.
Fantastic Beasts, also due out in November, is the ninth Harry Potter movie of sorts. I guess this is the book that Harry reads/studies from in the books? That's neat. J.K. Rowling is writing the screenplay which is cool, and it's being directed by David Yates, most famous for directing the two Deathly Hallows movies, also known as two of the three Harry Potter movies I've ever seen.
I hate Eddie Redmayne. And, no surprise, his character is the one I'm the least interested in from this trailer. I always love me some Colin Farrell though, so it'll scratch that itch. Honestly, without some semblance of an idea of who these characters are, I can't find myself getting excited for anything other than the amazing visuals. The Potterverse is blessed with an amazing costume designer (Colleen Atwood) and production designers (Stuart Craig and I think Stephenie McMillan is working on this one as well), and unlike the early-2000s Potter movies, the visuals in this look pretty great, even if that big-nosed creature at the 1:20 mark looks a little wonky and probably could've been pulled off better with really great makeup. Unless he's like a two-foot fairy or a goblin or whatever Harry Potter shit.
I'm sure if I were a Harry Potter nerd there would be 400 things in this trailer for me to bitch about and find vague connections to things and notice minutia they changed from the book. But I'm only a movie nerd, so all I can say about this trailer is that the movie seems solid and Eddie Redmayne should take his award-winning cutesy boyish grin back to the world of sub-par modeling.
Was the shitty Pokemon movie news from Comic Con or did the news just come out the same week as Comic Con? Whatever, this week it came out that Legendary had acquired the rights to a live-action Pokemon movie shortly after Nintendo's announcement that they wanted to venture into filmmaking, and obviously coasting on the new-found success of Pokemon Go. Unfortunately, unlike my idea for a live-action Pokemon movie (sort of a Goonies-style thing with scrappy young kids who want to catch all the Pokemon to stop a bully or a mean adult or whatever kids' movie trope you want), they'll be making it a...Pikachu detective movie? Fuck it, it can't be as bad as the emoji movie, I guess.
One other snippet of news to come out of Comic Con so far that I enjoyed was the putting to bed of rumors that Brie Larson would be cast in the titular role of Captain Marvel in 2019, with Marvel Studios making the official announcement this week and Brie tweeting this absolutely perfect photograph. Marvel's string of fairly decent blockbusters and my undying love for Brie Larson should make Captain Marvel a fun time in... three years. Anyway, on to the trailers.
First up is the second trailer for Marvel's Doctor Strange, out this November. I know absolutely nothing about Doctor Strange the character, and the connection between being a surgeon and a sorcerer is kind of wonky to me but I'm sure there'll be ample reasoning given that this is an origin story movie. Between the kaleidoscope Marvel logo, the ripple punch in the skyscraper, the shards of air, and the window and pillar perspective tomfoolery, this movie looks set to have second-half-of-Inception-level mindfuck visual effects, which I'm all for - and it'll probably look palpably dope in 3D, which is great for my eyes as well as Kevin Feige's wallet. Chiwetel Ejiofor's wi-fi crack at the end shows that this will have Marvel's requisite bordering-on-fourth-wall-breaking snarky quips, which is welcome until it inevitably becomes stale after their 40th movie.
And while I love Mads Mikkelsen and he looks baller as the main villain, it looks like this movie will be devolving into another pretty typical Marvel "god-man destroys the entire planet" effects party of a climax. Which is fine, but like, we gotta switch it up soon. Oh well, we got Guardians 2 in 10 months.
Fantastic Beasts, also due out in November, is the ninth Harry Potter movie of sorts. I guess this is the book that Harry reads/studies from in the books? That's neat. J.K. Rowling is writing the screenplay which is cool, and it's being directed by David Yates, most famous for directing the two Deathly Hallows movies, also known as two of the three Harry Potter movies I've ever seen.
I hate Eddie Redmayne. And, no surprise, his character is the one I'm the least interested in from this trailer. I always love me some Colin Farrell though, so it'll scratch that itch. Honestly, without some semblance of an idea of who these characters are, I can't find myself getting excited for anything other than the amazing visuals. The Potterverse is blessed with an amazing costume designer (Colleen Atwood) and production designers (Stuart Craig and I think Stephenie McMillan is working on this one as well), and unlike the early-2000s Potter movies, the visuals in this look pretty great, even if that big-nosed creature at the 1:20 mark looks a little wonky and probably could've been pulled off better with really great makeup. Unless he's like a two-foot fairy or a goblin or whatever Harry Potter shit.
I'm sure if I were a Harry Potter nerd there would be 400 things in this trailer for me to bitch about and find vague connections to things and notice minutia they changed from the book. But I'm only a movie nerd, so all I can say about this trailer is that the movie seems solid and Eddie Redmayne should take his award-winning cutesy boyish grin back to the world of sub-par modeling.
"Does Batman live in Bruce Wayne's basement?"
"No, Bruce Wayne lives in Batman's attic."
God, this movie's gonna be great. I'm really happy this movie is carrying over the absolutely beautiful computer-animation-faking-stop-motion-animation style from the first Lego Movie. And the casting is brilliant - Will Arnett as Batman, Zach Galifianakis as the Joker, and Michael freakin' Cera as Robin, who seems hilarious in his bits in this trailer. The creation of his costume was so clever and hilarious. Phil Lord and Chris Miller should be proud.
It seems Alfred will be playing a larger role than I thought in this, acting as Batman's dad in the most comedic sense possible. I'm hoping he's a fleshed-out character rather than just a comic relief, as it seems the Batman/Robin duo will have more than enough of the "comic" aspect down. While this trailer didn't really have the comedic timing perfection of the original two teasers, there were a lot of good funny bits in it. And I'm glad they're teasing out the Joker. Long story short, my body is ready for the Lego cinematic universe.
Okay, I'm cheating because this isn't a Comic Con trailer and it's a TV movie, but come on, this trailer came out today and how am I not gonna talk about it? I'm definitely gonna watch this when it premieres, even though all signs point to it absolutely sucking. I would say the girl is kind of cute but I have a sneaking suspicion she's underage so I'm gonna not do that even though I just did.
Anyway, this looks like shit. Just bring back the game show. No one watched Legends of the Hidden Temple for its deep lore and enticing backstory. We watched it because it was hilarious to watch bewildered children stumble around on a styrofoam TV set and suck dick at solving puzzles (okay, the bit with the silver monkey in the trailer was pretty funny). And to hear Olmec crack puns to the coked-up host. This movie is trying to pander to 25-year-olds who love the show but uses humor for the 13-and-younger crowd. And since Legends of the Hidden Temple wasn't exactly the epitome of world-building (which it really didn't have to be being a game show), this is essentially just "three dumb kids walk around in a generic cave with some Olmec jokes".
Also, are these kids, like, Nickelodeon celebrities or something? They seem perfect for it, and if not, I dunno why they didn't go with more bankable child actors for this dumpster fire of a movie. Are they fucking Vine famous? Christ, they probably are.
Okay, this movie looks pretty dumb, I'll admit it. But it looks like a lot of wacky fantasy fun. I honestly pictured this as much more drab and straightforward with British guys talking about things and then like, maybe a gritty war scene in the rain at the end. I guess I should've expected something more stylish coming from Guy Ritchie, and this looks like a lot of fun. That giant elephant thing and the burning skull knight... thing both look really cool. And I do love screaming men stabbing each other and stuff like that.
I wish I had more to say. I'll see this movie.
I wish I had more to say. I'll see this movie.
Tom Hiddleston? Brie Larson? Samuel L. Jackson? John Goodman!? Oh my God, this movie's got quite the cast.
So, this is the second film in Warner Bros's classic monsters cinematic universe. Apparently the plan is to pair up Godzilla and King Kong in the future, which would be absolutely bananas, especially considering, based on the sparse images that this trailer shows of him, Kong is massive in this movie. Glad they're sticking with the Godzilla method of teasing him in the trailers. I'm sure tons of people will piss and moan again about Kong only being in like 10% of the movie like they did with Godzilla a couple years back. Did people really expect the whole movie to revolve around Godzilla rather than him just being the main threat? Sure, it's called Godzilla, but it's not about him going to his day job and finding love and reconnecting with his estranged son. He's a giant lizard; any more than 10 minutes would be overkill. Plus, this way we get more time to stare at Brie Larson and Tom Hiddleston's hot faces.
As for the look of this film, man, did it also blow my expectations away. I thought this would be a fairly generic-looking action blockbuster, but this movie's use of color on the island seems really effective, especially in those bits where they're in the misty graveyard with the giant bones that's lit by the sickly yellow color. And Skull Island itself looks surprisingly lush and pretty. And that pan-up shot to Kong's lower half from the helicopters will probably make for a jaw-dropping reveal in the theater. Yeah, this'll probably be a good IMAX movie. Color me suddenly interested in Kong: Skull Island.
So, this is the second film in Warner Bros's classic monsters cinematic universe. Apparently the plan is to pair up Godzilla and King Kong in the future, which would be absolutely bananas, especially considering, based on the sparse images that this trailer shows of him, Kong is massive in this movie. Glad they're sticking with the Godzilla method of teasing him in the trailers. I'm sure tons of people will piss and moan again about Kong only being in like 10% of the movie like they did with Godzilla a couple years back. Did people really expect the whole movie to revolve around Godzilla rather than him just being the main threat? Sure, it's called Godzilla, but it's not about him going to his day job and finding love and reconnecting with his estranged son. He's a giant lizard; any more than 10 minutes would be overkill. Plus, this way we get more time to stare at Brie Larson and Tom Hiddleston's hot faces.
As for the look of this film, man, did it also blow my expectations away. I thought this would be a fairly generic-looking action blockbuster, but this movie's use of color on the island seems really effective, especially in those bits where they're in the misty graveyard with the giant bones that's lit by the sickly yellow color. And Skull Island itself looks surprisingly lush and pretty. And that pan-up shot to Kong's lower half from the helicopters will probably make for a jaw-dropping reveal in the theater. Yeah, this'll probably be a good IMAX movie. Color me suddenly interested in Kong: Skull Island.
Yeah, so apparently, we have a full trailer for the Justice League movie. Not a teaser, but a full-fledged trailer, even though we're 16 months out from release. I mean, I'm not complaining. Just weird.
I gotta say, this looks like the most solid Zack Snyder movie probably ever. As not much of a fan of 300 or really any of his other films, I was happy to see some actual character and humor brought in, especially after the dour, borderline nihilist Batman v Superman. Wonder Woman and Bruce Wayne's little chat about Aquaman (who I still don't think I'll be able to take seriously) clues us in that they'll have some actual chemistry, which is a quality that was suspiciously missing from the entirety of the last DC film. Although it seems Zack Snyder's color palette is still limited to white, black, and gray. And the new inclusion of the Flash will only exacerbate his most obnoxious directorial signature of excessive slow-motion (I mean, Christ, that Batarang catch was like a third of the trailer). But if we can have a silly Snyder-y movie with significantly less Snyder-y characters, I'll take it. Baby steps.
I gotta say, this looks like the most solid Zack Snyder movie probably ever. As not much of a fan of 300 or really any of his other films, I was happy to see some actual character and humor brought in, especially after the dour, borderline nihilist Batman v Superman. Wonder Woman and Bruce Wayne's little chat about Aquaman (who I still don't think I'll be able to take seriously) clues us in that they'll have some actual chemistry, which is a quality that was suspiciously missing from the entirety of the last DC film. Although it seems Zack Snyder's color palette is still limited to white, black, and gray. And the new inclusion of the Flash will only exacerbate his most obnoxious directorial signature of excessive slow-motion (I mean, Christ, that Batarang catch was like a third of the trailer). But if we can have a silly Snyder-y movie with significantly less Snyder-y characters, I'll take it. Baby steps.
I can't say I'm a huge fan of Ezra Miller from this trailer. His "I need friends" line was funny, but his dialogue and mannerisms in this trailer just give me this weird inkling of a feeling that his quippiness and awkwardness will most likely get on my nerves quickly. But, we have literally over a year for that feeling to evolve. But, man, is Ben Affleck killing it as Bruce Wayne/Batman or what? I still can't believe people were outraged that Affleck would be Batman. I always assumed he'd be one of the better parts of Batman v Superman, and I was right. And he looks like he's fully slipped into the role in this one, and he looks to be having a lot of fun.
"Well, that's neat."
Isn't it nice to see DC having characters that aren't soulless Hot Topic shirts? Anyway, this is the last one I'll be talking about because this is by far my favorite trailer out of Comic Con so far, barring a Rogue One one later. I said earlier that the best part of Batman v Superman was Ben Affleck, and my second and third favorite things were Wonder Woman and the fight choreography. DC seems to really know how to film gritty, in-the-dirt, up-close combat that just feels visceral and is like nerd boner Viagra. That was evident in BvS, and it seems even more evident here. The mid-air bow shot, the hand-to-lasso combat in that warehouse-looking place that looks straight out of an Arkham game, the blocking of mortar with the Shield of Whatever - I don't have any constructive analysis of these things; they just look cool. Which is all a Comic Con trailer needs to do.
The World War I setting seems interesting. It looks like it'll provide some really nice lavish sets and costumes, which I'm a minor dweeb for. And Gal Gadot is Wonder Woman; she looks great. It also helps that she's freaking gorgeous, of course, but y'know. I'm sure the secretary/slavery bit and "what I do is not up to you" bit will be called feminist-pandering by like four people on the Internet, but I just see it as her character being a badass. But don't worry, I fully expect dozens of thinkpieces on the political implications of every frame of this movie from now until its release. I'll just enjoy the movie.
But yeah, this looks like a good one, and the rest of DC's slate looks fairly solid so far. Overall, I'm enjoying what's coming out of Comic Con and will write up another quick post if any other trailers come out.
Also - I've been wanting to review the new Ghostbusters, which I know I'm super late on, but I'm finally home from vacation tomorrow night, so I'll try to get it out by Monday or Tuesday. I want to get the releases I've been slacking on squared away because August is gonna be pretty packed. So yeah, stay tuned for that.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
















